Daniel Keep wrote:

hasen wrote:
...

Wow, tortoisegit? Seems so bloated, look at those screen shots, it's so
confusing!

Wow, git cli?  Seems so bloated, look at all those commands, it's so
confusing!

It *is* confusing, it doesn't claim to be intuitive, it's aimed for developers, they're supposed to read tutorials/man pages to know how it works.

Providing a gui that maps a "pull" button to a pull command is confusing because GUI's are supposed to be "discoverable" and "intuitive".

No wonder I never knew how to properly use svn, I was so dependant on those GUIs, that I never knew what was going on under the surface.

At least for me, the only sensible way to use svn is through the command line.

GUIs for svn and git are confusing because well, you're not exactly sure what they're doing.



As for your assertion that tortoisegit is confusing, let's look at those
screenshots.

The first is a context-dependant list of git commands.  If you think
that's confusing, then I can't imagine you're able to use the git cli at
all, so let's assume you don't mean that one.

Yes, I think it's confusing. Read above.

I do use the git cli, it's easier because it makes more sense.


Next we have a shot of it detecting a patch set and giving you context
commands for those.  I fail to see how that could be confusing.

I haven't used patches with git, so I don't know what's in that corner of git.


The commit dialog?  Well, that's basically git commit -a, except you can
actually modify what files are being committed in the dialog itself and
it has a built-in editor.

Yea? What are these options? [Sign] [OK] what's the difference between them?


Actually, if you look at them, the dialogs are all just GUI versions of
the various git tools themselves.  So if you really find those
confusing, I can only assume you find Git itself confusing.

Look at this and tell me it's not confusing:
http://www.jensroesner.de/wgetgui/wgetgui.png


IMO it's wrong to just put the same command-line commands on the
right-click menu, and call that a gui.

Yes, because heaven forbid anyone makes our lives as developers easier.
 After all, no developer should EVER use a simplified interface when
what they SHOULD be doing is memorising every command and all of its
switches.

The heresy!

Well, if it makes your life easier, good for you.


The humble git-gui is much better.

Integrating those commands into the shell itself so that only the
commands that make sense in context are shown, and actually tell the
user what they're going to do is much better.

Incidentally, I use both.  TortoiseGit is great for anything of relative
complexity as it actually helps you do it correctly (it took me a while
to work out how to properly apply patch sets without it).

What's more, it also helps you learn how to use git without constantly
screwing up.

I think if you don't know what you're doing you'll screw up anyway. I used to use SmartSVN, TortoiseSVN, and probably some other GUIs, and every so often I would screw something up and have no idea how to fix it.

Why? because the GUI made me feel comfortable using svn without really knowing what the hell was going on. Many items under menus were confusing as hell. Many options for various tasks were also confusing as hell.

Reply via email to