Reply to hasen,

BCS wrote:

It seems you don't like GUIs. Obviously, others doesn't agree with
you.


Now, git comes with its own set of concepts, that are completely
different from svn. "checkout" in git has nothing to do with
"checkout" in svn. What's a branch? what's merging? where/how does
merging happen?

There's just no way you could work with git without knowing about all
of this. It's not complicated or anything, but you have to learn it.

So, when you learn to use it from the command line, then what's the
point of the gui?

See, because I come from windows, GUI to me means that I don't have to
learn anything; that I can just sail through it and it will somehow
work out on its own.

That's why GUIs that just offer buttons that map directly to CLI
commands are confusing.

OK I see where you are coming from and why we are seeing things so differently. To me, a GUI is not about "It just works" kinds of things. That's just good design and can be had (with more design work) in a CLI as well. To me, a GUI is about having more dimensions of input, more simultaneous channels of communication. I can see many different bits of information in a non linear way. I can have many contexts available at the same time. I can access many action from the same point. I'd much rather select from a set of files with check boxes than by typing in file names.


Imagine a file explorer where you have to right click a directory and
choose "cd" from the menu. and then it will cd into that directory,
but not show you the files inside it, instead it shows a blank, and
then you right click somewhere in that empty area and choose "ls".
better yet, "ls" would bring a sub-menu, where one of the choices is
"-al", or maybe just be smart and write it out as "all", to confuse
the user, and make him think "Oh, so it usually lists the first 10
files only unless I choose all? To conserve screen space maybe?"


There is a big difference; with Git/SVN many of the commands have side effect and many of the others take a bit of time and space to operate on. The way I've got SVN/Git set up the most useful information (file status) is shown right up front as icon overlays. I don't /want/ any more information that that because the next most useful bits (diffs for instance) wouldn't fit on any screen I could use.


Reply via email to