On Saturday, 31 January 2015 at 20:55:11 UTC, Jonathan Marler
wrote:
On Saturday, 31 January 2015 at 14:06:20 UTC, Piotrek wrote:
Hi,
The history of std.(experimental.)logger and the latest thread
about gui functionality inclusion into Phobos made me think
about how to solve the problem of adding new modules.
I came up with the idea (maybe not new) to create a additional
library(along druntime and Phobos) delivered with dmd package
and named "Mars" (Deimos is unfortunately already taken ).
The library itself would be driven by community (not
individual library developer) in order to be... the standard.
The process would be something similar to that other
committees use
(e.g
http://www.iec.ch/standardsdev/how/processes/development/)
where before the standard is approved it goes through a draft
stage. Still a draft can be used to create a working product
(e.g. some Wi-Fi solutions based on IEEE 802.11 drafts)
Possible initial prerequisites:
- User awareness about the usage consequences
- Library placed at https://github.com/D-Programming-Language/
- Only well recognized community members have pull rights
- design decision made on the best known sw engineering
patterns used in D
- New module should be functional with D/Phobos standards
applied
- API and implementation allowed to change any time in order
to make a progress
- no external dependencies beside OS services
- "draft" as the root module name e.g. "module draft.gui"
Advantages:
- community driven process which ensures the lowest level of
controversy
- fast path for modules like GUI to be standardized
Disadvantages:
- additional effort for the sw release process
Ready to be destroyed ;)
Piotrek
I approve :) +1
Thanks for your vote.
If there is no official veto to the proposal, I will create a DIP
in a day or two.
Meanwhile, we can still discuss unclear or problematic issues.
Piotrek
