On Saturday, 13 June 2015 at 08:37:57 UTC, Mike wrote:
I would like to see this vote happen before 2.068.
Unfortunately, Dicebot is not longer the review manager.
Who wants to count yes/no/(my logger is better) votes in a
forum thread?
Is that really all there is to it (counting votes in a thread)?
If so, I'll do it.
Mike
The vote tally on the Review Queue page (6-yes, 6-no) does not
agree with the vote tally on the std.experimental.logger review
page (6-yes, 7-no). Furthermore, no one on the Phobos team voted
yes (perhaps not a problem, but a concern).
Documentation on the voting process [3] doesn't state what
constitutes approval. If it is majority only, then according to
the std.experimental.logger review [2], it shouldn't have even
made it into std.experimental. Some clarification here would be
helpful.
[1] Review Queue - http://wiki.dlang.org/Review_Queue
[2] std.experimental.logger Review Page -
http://wiki.dlang.org/Review/std.logger#Voting_for_std.experimental
[3] Voting Process - http://wiki.dlang.org/Review/Process#Voting
Mike
