On Tue, 09 Feb 2010 12:42:46 -0500, Andrei Alexandrescu <[email protected]> wrote:

Steven Schveighoffer wrote:
On Tue, 09 Feb 2010 10:53:47 -0500, Steve Teale <[email protected]> wrote:

When D2 is 'frozen', as a special treat would it be possible for it to be
able to generate object files that could be converted into shared
libraries, and for Phobos to be a shared library to support same.

I have tried every which way I can think of to create shared libraries
using D. The closest I have come is with the old 1.030 GDC, and even with that there are problems. I've tried to describe the current situation in
some detail on the blog section of my <a href="http://
www.britseyeview.com/GDC-newbie.html">GDC-newbie page</a>. It is too long
to post on the newsgroup.

The inability to do this is a real show-stopper for D on Linux, and
unless things have got better since I last tried, the same can be said
for Windows DLLs.

Please!
Many (including myself) have expressed the real requirement for shared libraries. Sometimes the response is "oh who needs shared libraries anyways, there is so much memory in todays computers" and the other response is that "Windows DLLs suck, so we can't do it". I agree it needs to be figured out before D is considered a viable professional language. I don't think it's impossible, but someone just needs to spend the time. Another new problem to pile on to Windows DLLs is the new requirement for default thread local storage. See this bug that is very unlikely to get fixed (by Microsoft):
 http://d.puremagic.com/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=3342
So the tradeoff is, either use crappy TLS (using a function to look up global variables) or only support Windows Vista and later. If Windows 7 hadn't come out, I'd say requiring Vista is about as bad as not having DLLs :)
 -Steve

A lot of Phobos consists of templates, which would be difficult to put in a shared library.

There is druntime, all the typeinfos, and much of phobos' templates will likely be used in other parts of phobos. For example, if an XML library is template based on the character width, but one part of phobos uses the xml library based on char (for properties or something), then instantiating that template with char in your program code will leave the char-generated version in the phobos dynamic lib.

The savings will be real. Most templated code is used in similar ways and so those uses can be consolidated into one shared library. It might even be worth pre-generating common templates even if they are not specifically used.

-Steve

Reply via email to