On Tue, 09 Feb 2010 16:28:27 -0500, Walter Bright <[email protected]> wrote:

Steven Schveighoffer wrote:
On Tue, 09 Feb 2010 15:58:37 -0500, Walter Bright <[email protected]> wrote:

Steve Teale wrote:
The inability to do this is a real show-stopper for D on Linux, and unless things have got better since I last tried, the same can be said for Windows DLLs.

The dmd/samples/d/dserver.d is an example of a Windows DLL in D.
According to Don (haven't tried, because I don't have a windows box handy), any D2 DLL will fail, even an empty one because of http://d.puremagic.com/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=3342

It is a bad problem, but it doesn't apply to implicitly loaded DLLs, only dynamically loaded ones, and it also doesn't apply to Vista or Windows 7.

But implicitly loaded DLLs aren't supported by D! However, I was not aware that it only applied to dynamically loaded ones, that is good to know.

That aside, having to handle manual steps to ensure the runtime doesn't lose its mind is unacceptable. It has to be handled without any manual runtime coding to be a viable solution. DDL is not a solution, its a hack. In other words, I should be able to flip a compiler switch to build a shared lib, and I shouldn't have to do anything special aside from exporting symbols. This is the way it is in all other programming languages. Until Phobos is a shared lib, I don't think we need to have any discussions about any existing solutions. That is requirement number 1 for saying D supports shared libs.

Shared libraries (on Linux) and Windows DLLs are very different things.

Yes, I agree they are two different problems to solve. But to a developer, they look the same.

Phobos as a DLL is a different problem than creating DLLs with D. DLLs in D can be created that are statically linked with Phobos, and that can be accessed by any executable in any language.

They can be accessed by another D program? My understanding is that all kinds of weird problems happen if you dynamically link two D programs together. I'm not speaking from first-hand experience, I may be wrong.

It is very important that Phobos be a dynamic library and that you can build dynamic libraries easily without manual manipulation of the runtime. If these two things are accomplished, then D can say it supports dynamic libraries, not before. Half ass support doesn't count. It's like saying a car has a cup holder because you can wedge your cup between the seat and the e-brake.

-Steve

Reply via email to