On 4/4/11 12:45 PM, Bruno Medeiros wrote:
Are you saying all this drama regarding D in Reddit is mostly because
it's D and a particular someone with an agenda regarding D, and is not
the general ambiance of Reddit?

Drama is always present where people are, but the particular hubbub surrounding D in reddit is largely (if not exclusively) the handiwork of one person (id iLiekCaeks). That person spares no effort to defame D and often Walter on reddit: brings D with a negative connotation with every remote opportunity; shows up ready to pick a fight (e.g. "how about that Tango vs. Phobos disaster?") every single time D is being discussed in any way, shape, or form; replies to every one of Walter's posts and finds issues with virtually everything he says. He is technically competent, stays current with D developments, and in fact could have many good points to make if he wanted to.

My staunch approach is finding unity and conciliation; I have recently had conversations with that person that revealed that our views are considerably more aligned than it might seem. Even he seemed to agree, with varied levels of grudginess, with some of the language design decisions that inevitably forge compromises because they need to satisfy conflicting requirements. At the end of the day, professionals will understand there are things that can't be disagreed about and other things in which reasonable people can disagree.

Because I rarely hear about or follow Reddit links outside of the D NG,
but when I do and check the discussions there, there is always some
controversy or flaming going on. I was starting to grow the impression
that Reddit is a huge troll cave (thus furthering my desire to avoid
it), so correct me if I'm wrong. (because on the other hand you seem to
favor posting stuff there a lot, versus other sites or news-aggregators)

Generally reddit has the nice property that articles towards the top are relatively informative. It is a source of information used by many professionals and therefore a very appropriate place for sharing D-related news to the larger community. Top-rated comments may be often informative but are occasionally just funny.

Reddit can be manipulated because their policy allows creating unlimited accounts and keeps them entirely private. That makes it relatively easy for a determined individual to use several accounts to comment, upvote, and downvote news.

Case in point: I have recently made four submissions to reddit: GTK+, iPad2 contest, GSoC 2011, and the Mago debugger. Of these, three have been classified as spam, even though they actually have been on the site, upvoted, and discussed mostly positively for hours. What I infer happens is that if enough accounts classify an article as "spam", the spam detector automatically bans the article. If that hypothesis is true, a determined individual who is willing to spend time on that kind of activity can effectively make an article disappear. I had to write the moderators to have the articles reinstated, but that happened only a day later when their novelty had already decayed.

One thing that I find a bit odd is that Walter and I need to do most of this all by ourselves, although there's significant pressure for us to do many other things for D. For example, after having suggested that the GTK+ news is shared on reddit and after having seen that not one soul cares to do that, I posted the article myself, followed up with moderators (twice) when it was manipulated into deletion, and made sure the article was reinstated.

Speaking of GtkD, I have difficulty understanding someone who is confident and persistent enough to carry through a major piece of work, yet refuses to take a simple step towards letting others know about it. Also, I get a good chuckle when seeing the occasional "I'm ready to do anything, how can I help D?" thread on digitalmars.D. Such is human nature.


Thanks,

Andrei

Reply via email to