Am 04.04.2011 20:56, schrieb Andrei Alexandrescu: > On 4/4/11 12:45 PM, Bruno Medeiros wrote: >> Are you saying all this drama regarding D in Reddit is mostly because >> it's D and a particular someone with an agenda regarding D, and is not >> the general ambiance of Reddit? > > Drama is always present where people are, but the particular hubbub > surrounding D in reddit is largely (if not exclusively) the handiwork of > one person (id iLiekCaeks). That person spares no effort to defame D and > often Walter on reddit: brings D with a negative connotation with every > remote opportunity; shows up ready to pick a fight (e.g. "how about that > Tango vs. Phobos disaster?") every single time D is being discussed in > any way, shape, or form; replies to every one of Walter's posts and > finds issues with virtually everything he says. He is technically > competent, stays current with D developments, and in fact could have > many good points to make if he wanted to. > > My staunch approach is finding unity and conciliation; I have recently > had conversations with that person that revealed that our views are > considerably more aligned than it might seem. Even he seemed to agree, > with varied levels of grudginess, with some of the language design > decisions that inevitably forge compromises because they need to satisfy > conflicting requirements. At the end of the day, professionals will > understand there are things that can't be disagreed about and other > things in which reasonable people can disagree. > >> Because I rarely hear about or follow Reddit links outside of the D NG, >> but when I do and check the discussions there, there is always some >> controversy or flaming going on. I was starting to grow the impression >> that Reddit is a huge troll cave (thus furthering my desire to avoid >> it), so correct me if I'm wrong. (because on the other hand you seem to >> favor posting stuff there a lot, versus other sites or news-aggregators) > > Generally reddit has the nice property that articles towards the top are > relatively informative. It is a source of information used by many > professionals and therefore a very appropriate place for sharing > D-related news to the larger community. Top-rated comments may be often > informative but are occasionally just funny. > > Reddit can be manipulated because their policy allows creating unlimited > accounts and keeps them entirely private. That makes it relatively easy > for a determined individual to use several accounts to comment, upvote, > and downvote news. > > Case in point: I have recently made four submissions to reddit: GTK+, > iPad2 contest, GSoC 2011, and the Mago debugger. Of these, three have > been classified as spam, even though they actually have been on the > site, upvoted, and discussed mostly positively for hours. What I infer > happens is that if enough accounts classify an article as "spam", the > spam detector automatically bans the article. If that hypothesis is > true, a determined individual who is willing to spend time on that kind > of activity can effectively make an article disappear. I had to write > the moderators to have the articles reinstated, but that happened only a > day later when their novelty had already decayed. > > One thing that I find a bit odd is that Walter and I need to do most of > this all by ourselves, although there's significant pressure for us to > do many other things for D. For example, after having suggested that the > GTK+ news is shared on reddit and after having seen that not one soul > cares to do that, I posted the article myself, followed up with > moderators (twice) when it was manipulated into deletion, and made sure > the article was reinstated. > > Speaking of GtkD, I have difficulty understanding someone who is > confident and persistent enough to carry through a major piece of work, > yet refuses to take a simple step towards letting others know about it. > Also, I get a good chuckle when seeing the occasional "I'm ready to do > anything, how can I help D?" thread on digitalmars.D. Such is human nature. > > > Thanks, > > Andrei
And on the other hand there's Gary Whatmore and his army of sockpuppets voting down D critics and giving the whole community a bad name with his extreme (pseudo-?) fanboyism.
