On Wednesday, August 31, 2011 23:56:04 dsimcha wrote: > Unless something has changed, the review of std.curl (formerly etc.curl > but I think there's some agreement now that it should be in std) ends > today. (David Naglinger is the review manager. David, please make this > official.) > > Since we have such an embarrassment of riches lately in terms of new > modules to be reviewed, we don't want bubbles in the review queue. The > first thing we need to decide is whether a review is allowed to run > concurrently with a vote. Andrei has suggested that reviews never run > concurrently with each other, and I agree. However, since the vote > stage takes up much less of the community's time, I think it's ok to run > a review and a vote concurrently with each other. > > Either way, here are the potential modules for next in the review queue. > Which ones are the highest priority and whether I missed any. > > std.log (Logging module by Jose Armando Garcia. High priority because > logging is a standard feature in modern languages.) > > std.regionallocator (A segmented stack/region memory allocator, by me. > I'd like to fast-track this because it's used by two of the GSoC > projects that were done this summer so getting it into Phobos would > simplify things.) > > CSV parser (By Jesse Phillips) > > std.variant (Massive overhaul that includes runtime reflection, by > Robert Jacques.) > > In case you read my last review queue status post, I've taken > std.process out of the pool because it needs a runtime fix on windows > and std.parallel_algorithm because I decided to make it more > comprehensive and need time to do so.
Given that no one else other than David Nadlinger (who just was the review manager, so he shouldn't have to do it this time around) has volunteered to be the review manager for the next round, I guess that I'll volunteer to do it. And based on this discussion, it looks like the region allocator is next. dsimcha, is there any reason not to start the review of the region allocator shortly? Does a review period of about 2 weeks, ending on Wednesday, the 21st sound good? - Jonathan M Davis
