Zeljko,

Hi Fagyal,

Domain ownership is determined by owner contact, but access to domain is
determined by access to profile, and its' username/password information. For
that reason, profile should closely resemble ownership, and best practice is
to use profile for all domains that belong to one user, and one user only.


That's correct.

It's really not a good practice to throw different people's domains into the
same profile.

Well, it's not about different people. User B *buys* the domain from user A, so he issues a transfer.

This is actually impossible for end-users to do on their own;


See above: user B issues the transfer, which is then acknowledged by user A. We do not even see the process here, it just takes place via our website.

As I mentioned earlier, the problem here is that user B thinks that because he has provided his own contact data when he submitted the order, these contact data will actually be associated with the domain, and not only with the order. If these contact data are not used, then why are they here? if they are used to associate data with the order, and not the domain, then why aren't there similar fields when a renewal order is placed?

when placing an order, if one want to assign it to the existing profile, one
needs to know username and password of that profile; end-user would not have
that information, unless it's the owner of the profile.

It's the owner's profile.

It's only service
providers that may do that, if they have u/p of their customers. Once again,
please don't do it, it's not a good practice, even if you manage domains of
all your customers. One example of the possible problems is the one you
described.

I understand, but I hope you see our problem now. Everything boils down to that nothing happens with the contact data provided for transfer orders.

- Csongor

Reply via email to