Leshek wrote:
That is a very good point Marc is making. The way I think about it, that REST is not really stateless :-) it requires state separation: application state - always on the client (what page is the client on); can use cookies fully client controlled
      resource state    - on the server (no cookies)

That's a good point. And I'll add that server RAM is still a good place for caching expensive resources, which is another typical use of the Servlet session.

In my case, I'm building a Facebook app. When I recognize a user I give them a cookie with their userid and some other application state information encrypted in the value. I then use that encrypted value as a key to a HashMap full of my own session objects.

If the session object goes away, that's fine; I can decrypt the cookie and re-fetch the Facebook friend info. But in the normal case, I don't have to decrypt anything, and I can give quick responses to interactive users. And to my mind it's reasonable RESTful, which keeps the architecture clean.

William

Reply via email to