I'll post roughly the same thing I posted in the German subforum ;)

I haven't tried it and I'm not going to. I think the price is too high
for a 3.5" *resistive* touchscreen. If you factor in the cost for a Pi +
DAC + PiScreen + custom case, you might as well buy a nice Android phone
with a ~4.5" touchscreen. Its display will be larger, its touchscreen
will be capacitive, and its screen resolution will be higher (720p).

I have two Pis myself and love them. But Android phones come
fully-loaded and outsell the Pi (and accessories for it) by orders of
magnitude. Recently, DACs in Android devices got much better, too. E.g.,
the DAC in the Moto G 8 GB (first gen) measures decently in RMAA.

I do understand the appeal of small-board computers with their
relatively open hardware/driver environment. However, in my mind, for
the purpose of a Touch-like squeezebox client, it's not that big of a
problem that a typical Android device is somewhat more locked down. The
essential apps (Squeeze Player/SB Player, OrangeSqueeze, etc.) still
run. Furthermore, you can open up the device a bit more by rooting.

I have a B+ running picoreplayer that's connected to my AV receiver. The
B+ plus all required parts did cost less than EUR 50 altogether (and it
would have been even cheaper had I reused an existing microSD and PSU).
Had I instead added an I2S DAC (EUR 30-50), a PiScreen (A$ 59.95 plus A$
20 shipping), and a custom case, I would have suddenly found myself at a
price point where there are a lot of other options.

I am not trying to put down respectable projects like the HifiBerry or
the PiScreen. If you have special requirements, they may just be a match
made in heaven. I'm just saying that, depending on your needs, cheap
mainstream devices may do the job as well.


------------------------------------------------------------------------
dafiend's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=60637
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=102281

_______________________________________________
diy mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/diy

Reply via email to