On Fri 18/Mar/2022 17:11:56 +0100 John R Levine wrote:

Repeating the tree walk, we'd get a different result if we find psd=y at _dmarc.f.c.d.  Is that realistic?

Yes, of course it is.  Look at some of the PSL entries.

I may be dumb, but I stared at the PSL for a few minutes and couldn't think of non-aligned subdomains of an org domain.

Look at these two:

repl.co
id.repl.co

so the example would be a.b.repl.co and c.id.repl.co


Let me use the PSL, as it works with fictitious domains.  I could find the org 
domain like so:

ale@pcale:~/tmp/zdkimfilter/svn/src$ ./TESTpublicsuffix 
../no-svn/public_suffix_list.dat a.b.repl.co
a.b.repl.co -> b.repl.co

So b.repl.co is the org domain.  c.id.repl.co doesn't end with that string, 
therefore it is not aligned.

I could also have run this:

ale@pcale:~/tmp/zdkimfilter/svn/src$ ./TESTpublicsuffix 
../no-svn/public_suffix_list.dat c.id.repl.co
c.id.repl.co -> c.id.repl.co

and conclude that it is not aligned because its org domain differs.  However, 
string comparison is easier, no?



Best
Ale
--






_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmarc

Reply via email to