Okay. That was my understanding, but wanted to make sure it was crystal clear. Thanks for the clarification.
On Thu, Mar 9, 2023, 2:53 PM John Levine <[email protected]> wrote: > It appears that Mark Alley <[email protected]> said: > >-=-=-=-=-=- > > > >This question probably has an obvious answer, but asking for > >clarification on this - Policy difference aside, in this example > >provided, does this mean with the Treewalk behavior, cuny.edu's DMARC > >feedback addresses that differ from the subdomain's would stop getting > >the sub's DMARC reports? > > Yes, that's a feature. If you want your subdomains to send reports to > some particular place, tell them to do that. If you don't, that's OK > too. > > Any domain can put a "rua" tag into its DMARC record so this isn't > really anything new. > > R's, > John > > >On 2/23/2023 6:13 PM, John R. Levine wrote: > >>> I haven’t done extensive research but here is a live example where > >>> treewalk will cause a result change. > >>> From: is in the domain Ret.bmcc.cuny.edu which has no DMARC record. > >>> _dmarc.bmcc.cuny.edu. 300 IN TXT "v=DMARC1; p=quarantine; > >>> fo=1; > >>> rua=mailto:[email protected]; > >>> ruf=mailto:[email protected]"; > >>> > >>> _dmarc.cuny.edu. 3325 IN TXT "v=DMARC1;" "p=none;" > >>> "rua=mailto:[email protected],mailto: > [email protected];" > >>> > >>> "ruf=mailto:[email protected],mailto: > [email protected];" > >>> "fo=1" > >> > >> Good catch, although in this case I think the most likely result is > >> that the people at bmcc.cuny.edu will say "who set up > >> Ret.bmcc.cuny.edu?" I see that bmcc.cuny.edu and cuny.edu both use > >> Proofpoint in front of O365, while Ret.bmcc.cuny.edu goes directly to > >> O365. There's some other strangeness; www.cuny.edu is a CNAME for > >> web.cuny.edu which has an MX to mail-relay.cuny.edu. which has 7 A > >> records pointing to machines running sendmail. > >> > >> It might be interesting to set up a web page where you can put in a > >> mail domain and it'll tell you whether its treatment will change with > >> the tree walk. >
_______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmarc
