On Tue, Apr 1, 2025 at 3:02 PM Todd Herr <todd= 40someguyinva....@dmarc.ietf.org> wrote:
> So, as co-editor for DMARCbis, I want to make sure I'm crystal clear on > how this impacts the way forward... > > - Right now, DMARCbis rev -40 exists, and IANA has opened a > case/ticket/issue/whatever term they use to refer to it, namely [IANA > #1415214] > - The points they raise in that case are minor, all related to text > and tables in Section 9 of DMARCbis, but rev -41 will have to be generated > to address it. > > You can resolve those and post a new version if they are indeed minor and wouldn't need to affirm WG or IETF consensus before shipping. Anything that's a bigger deal will need AD coordination. > > - After that, there will be a period of six months plus however long > it takes to charter this new group, where DMARCbis will lay fallow. At the > conclusion of this new working group's work, there will either be nothing > to do to DMARCbis (because the failure reporting document will exist), OR > DMARCbis will need to be updated at that point to say "failure reporting is > deprecated" and all references to the failure reporting document will be > removed. (The editors have estimated this to be a task that might take > eight hours or so, so figure sixteen hours.) > > I don't know about "After that"; you could resolve the IANA work while you wait for everything else to resolve. Beyond that, it will hold in the RFC Editor queue until the missing reference to the failure reporting document resolves. That could happen because the failure reporting document somehow makes it to the RFC Editor queue (completing the document cluster), or the references are changed to Informative (dangling references to Informational documents are allowed), or they are removed (removing the dangling reference altogether). It may not take six months to get us to one of those conclusions. Miracles happen. -MSK >
_______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list -- dmarc@ietf.org To unsubscribe send an email to dmarc-le...@ietf.org
