On Thu, May 28, 2026 at 8:58 AM Alessandro Vesely <[email protected]> wrote:

>      ### The Missing Authorization Layer
>
>      ARC, much like DMARC itself, ultimately leaves delivery decisions to
>      local receiver policy.  A receiver evaluating a DMARC failure may
> decide
>      to override the domain owner's published policy when a valid ARC chain
>      is present.  In practice, this override depends on the degree of trust
>      the receiver places in the ARC sealer.
>
>      From the perspective of intermediaries such as mailing lists and
>      forwarders, this behavior is fundamentally unpredictable.  A forwarder
>      has no practical way to determine whether a receiver trusts a given
> ARC
>      sealer, or under which conditions that trust applies.  As a
> consequence,
>      mailing lists largely abandoned reliance on downstream ARC evaluation
>      and instead chose to assume responsibility for the message in the
> DMARC
>      sense, typically by rewriting the From: header field.
>

I've read this over a couple of times, and I'm not convinced that the
proposed text adds something that's sorely missing.

If we feel like we really need to expand on what might have made ARC
better, IMHO these two paragraphs say enough.  I'm not totally comfortable
with the last sentence in the second paragraph though, because I don't know
that list developers or at-scale operators even gave ARC anything beyond a
cursory review; the From: field rewriting may have been the path they chose
to follow independently.

-MSK
_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to