> On Jul 6, 2026, at 6:56 AM, Isamu Koga <[email protected]> 
> wrote:
> 
>> I think we should NOT make ARC historic, yet.
>> 
>> 1. ARC is actively deployed and utilized
>> 2. No interoperable replacement is yet published
> 
> I totally agree with Seth.
> 
> It is too early to make ARC Historic at this point.  ARC may eventually be
> deprecated, but no interoperable replacement exists today.  If a customer
> were to ask what interoperable alternative is currently available, I would
> not have a good answer.

I get it, technology marches on, but...

I am so tired of the "next great thing that's going to fix email that admins of 
both sending servers and receivers alike need to figure out how to staple in to 
their infrastructure even if it ignores some 
edge-case-thats-not-an-edge-case-at-all."

network-operators-actually-paying-attention-to-abuse@
RBL's
SPF with TXT records
SPF with SPF RRTYPES
No wait, SPF with TXT records (but not _spf.domain, let's continue to overload 
the apex).
MS Sender-ID with its wierd licensing requirements that no admin can agree to 
without contacting Legal.
Lets-put-a-haiku-in-your-headers and use that to assert copyright
Hashcash
The CAN-SPAM act
Domainkeys
DKIM
DKIM-Reputation
ADSP
SenderScore
SPEWS (and about 3 dozen other RBLs that will randomly return bad codes)
DMARC
DMARCbis
ARC
MTA-STS
BIMI

and...even if you do the right things according to the above, you can still get 
delivery issues to $big_mailbox, which will have its own vague rules and 
requirements.

After which, someone can STILL put "Paypal Official Support" 
<[email protected]> in their legitimate From header, fully signed, 
and pretty much every MUA out there won't flag it (or even display it) because 
that's "too confusing for the users", so either way mail admins are forced to 
put forwarding-breaking WARNING: EXTERNAL ORGANIZAION mime bodies in their mail.

If you want operator burnout, this is the way.

I'm sure the proponents of DKIM2 are going to be real proud of their new 
sliced-bread machine when it comes out and totally solves everything, no this 
time for real, but the time to deprecate ARC is *after* it's out, IMHO.  Maybe 
make it easier for admins to have a flag day to do both things?

-Dan
_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to