All, please do not reply to this message, as it's not on topic for this thread and I don't want the thread to veer off.
Thanks, Barry, as chair On Thu, Jul 9, 2026 at 12:57 PM Dan Mahoney <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > On Jul 6, 2026, at 6:56 AM, Isamu Koga <[email protected]> > > wrote: > > > >> I think we should NOT make ARC historic, yet. > >> > >> 1. ARC is actively deployed and utilized > >> 2. No interoperable replacement is yet published > > > > I totally agree with Seth. > > > > It is too early to make ARC Historic at this point. ARC may eventually be > > deprecated, but no interoperable replacement exists today. If a customer > > were to ask what interoperable alternative is currently available, I would > > not have a good answer. > > I get it, technology marches on, but... > > I am so tired of the "next great thing that's going to fix email that admins > of both sending servers and receivers alike need to figure out how to staple > in to their infrastructure even if it ignores some > edge-case-thats-not-an-edge-case-at-all." > > network-operators-actually-paying-attention-to-abuse@ > RBL's > SPF with TXT records > SPF with SPF RRTYPES > No wait, SPF with TXT records (but not _spf.domain, let's continue to > overload the apex). > MS Sender-ID with its wierd licensing requirements that no admin can agree to > without contacting Legal. > Lets-put-a-haiku-in-your-headers and use that to assert copyright > Hashcash > The CAN-SPAM act > Domainkeys > DKIM > DKIM-Reputation > ADSP > SenderScore > SPEWS (and about 3 dozen other RBLs that will randomly return bad codes) > DMARC > DMARCbis > ARC > MTA-STS > BIMI > > and...even if you do the right things according to the above, you can still > get delivery issues to $big_mailbox, which will have its own vague rules and > requirements. > > After which, someone can STILL put "Paypal Official Support" > <[email protected]> in their legitimate From header, fully signed, > and pretty much every MUA out there won't flag it (or even display it) > because that's "too confusing for the users", so either way mail admins are > forced to put forwarding-breaking WARNING: EXTERNAL ORGANIZAION mime bodies > in their mail. > > If you want operator burnout, this is the way. > > I'm sure the proponents of DKIM2 are going to be real proud of their new > sliced-bread machine when it comes out and totally solves everything, no this > time for real, but the time to deprecate ARC is *after* it's out, IMHO. > Maybe make it easier for admins to have a flag day to do both things? > > -Dan > _______________________________________________ > dmarc mailing list -- [email protected] > To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] _______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
