Tero's situation is a very interesting solution to the problems inherent
with auto-forwarding, a topic which we have not discussed very much.

Auto-forwarding has significant problems managing unwanted email:

   - The forwarder has incentives to weaken filtering rules to avoid false
   positives.   Clients do not want to hunt for lost messages in two places.
   - Forwarded organization have difficulty evaluating forwarded mail
   accurately.    Spam in the forwarded stream may cause the evaluator to give
   the forwarder a negative reputation, also causing lost messages.   Because
   of this, forwarding clients will seek out environments that allow them to
   whitelist their forwarding point.   Collectively, this means that most spam
   filtering occurs by the user, rather than by a filter at an organization
   boundary.
   - These problems have not been discussed because forwarding is assumed
   to preserve DKIM signatures and therefore be exempt from DMARC-related
   false positives.


Tero's organization has taken a unique approach to these challenges:


   - They perform spam filtering without blocking.   The spam results are
   coded into the messages, causing DKIM failures, and creating the
   possibility of DMARC-related false positives.
   - Without ARC, clients can only use forwarded organizations which do not
   block DMARC failure.
   - With ARC, clients can chose forwarded organizations which do not block
   DMARC failure or which accept ARC information from the forwarding
   organization.
   - Forwarded organization that use the supplied ARC information can
   perform spam filtering accurately, including reputation tests based on
   identity.    Organizations which use the ARC information to perform
   filtering will offload spam risk from the client while having low rates of
   false positives.
   - Clients are willing to accept primary responsibility for spam
   filtering, because the embedded risk indicators allow them to send unwanted
   messages to dead-end folders.
   - A request to trust a specific ARC source, on behalf of a specific
   user, is a mechanism for users to notify their organization about forwarded
   mail streams.
   - Overall, clients are better served by organizations that trust ARC by
   request than by organizations which ignore both DMARC and ARC.

This design will encounter challenges when the ARC chain begins prior to
the forwarding point.   The greatest problems will occur when the ARC set
is broken and when an earlier ARC set has incorrect results reported.
 Nonetheless, it becomes clear to me when Tero expects harm if ARC support
is removed from the organizations that currently receive his forwarded mail.

Whether DKIM2 will provide him with a sufficient replacement for ARC is
unclear to me.   But he has time to influence that process.

In the meantime, organizations that accept forwarded mail streams need to
come forward to discuss what they need and what they are willing to accept.

Doug Foster

On Thu, Jul 9, 2026 at 10:48 AM Tero Kivinen <[email protected]> wrote:

> Douglas Foster writes:
> > Tero, I am always confused by your posts.  Are you operating a
> > server for just yourself?
>
> Me, and 30000 other members, but we only forward messages, we do not
> offer end mailboxes. And we do implement ARC, and my own personal
> server (where my emails are forwarded) do check ARC headers. Each user
> provides an address (or list of addresses) where his emails are
> forwarded, and they can change it when they change mailbox providers
> etc.
>
> > It appears that you, acing as system manager, knows what messages
> > you, acting as recipient, want delivered.
>
> Yes, they usually want everything... Most of our users consider email
> reliability to be most important factor for them. Almost all of the
> support questions are about important emails not being delivered to
> the end recipient.
>
> Users also have settings to tell what they want, i.e., in iki.fi
> members can ask spam marking (feed email through spamassassin and
> record its findings to in few different ways). Or they can ask for
> spam mark step to be bypassed, so they get all the emails and filter
> them themselves.
>
> > In the general case, most system administrators do not have a
> > process in place to know what their users want.
>
> My general feeling when talking to the end users is that they want all
> the emails delivered, but sorted to spam and non spam mailboxes, so
> they can go and try to find the emails from spam mailbox when the
> system misclassified the email. What they do not like is that email
> never was accepted by system at all, so they have to send email to the
> sender and ask them to deliver it using some other way.
>
> We currently do also offer a service that allows users to see all
> their emails received by iki.fi system, i.e., users can ask iki.fi to
> set up a www-backup mailbox for them, and then their emails are also
> forwarded to that read-only www-mailbox where they are stored for
> 7-days and after that they are automatically deleted. This is intended
> for the users to find which emails their main mail provider decided to
> delete for some reason.
> --
> [email protected]
>
_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to