Hi all,

The second paragraph in Section 3.1 states:

   *  Internet-scale dependency on reputation: For broad
      interoperability, ARC required evaluators to run a reputation
      system for ARC signers.  Verifying the cryptography was necessary
      but insufficient; evaluators needed to decide whether to trust
      each signer in the chain before using their assertions to override
      DMARC outcomes.  This created a parallel trust infrastructure,
      separate from (but interacting with) existing domain or IP
      reputation.

I'm puzzled by the role of "each signer in the chain". There should be a clear distinction between signers whose ARC-Message-Signature still verifies and signers that signed before the message was modified. The oldest-pass value, defined as optional by the RFC, indicates how far back the evaluator can consider assertions from signers whose reputation it trusts. Treating trust in the chain as if it applied indiscriminately to every signer seems to be related to the misunderstanding behind the Yahoo problem recently discussed.

Having "Internet-scale" and "reputation" in the same sentence also puzzles me. It seems to suggest that domain reputation can somehow propagate through the Internet. Likewise, the "parallel trust infrastructure" is not really explained. What exactly is that infrastructure? These concepts are implicitly assumed by the RFC, not explicitly defined. So, if we use them to explain ARC's failure, we have to say what they are supposed to be.


Best
Ale
--





_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to