Hi Alex, Added to the point you made, I have concerns on
Enhanced mobility anchoring work item text and the references made there (BTW among others). The RFCs cited there, RFC 6097, 6463, and 5142 all progressed after the base protocol was developed, RFC 3775 or MIPv6 for 5142 and RFC 5213 or PMIPv6 for 6097 and 6363. They were extensions to what the protocol had offering some more advanced methods. My concern is DMM is being rechartered to develop the base solution. How could the base protocol be held to such a high standard even before its existence? I have similar concerns on the other work items and I think they carry similar sense. My suggestion is a base DMM protocol as an integrated solution has to be developed first and not developed in so many pieces. And then bring those three work items (or similar) up as a rechartering issue. Regards, Behcet On Wed, Oct 8, 2014 at 9:23 AM, Alexandru Petrescu <[email protected]> wrote: > Jouni, > > Thank you for the message. > > Here are the modifications: > > Where the Charter mentions "Mobile IPv6 protocol family (RFC x, y, z)" it > should also mention RFC 3963 and RFC 5177. > > (these RFCs were mentioned in past versions but disappeared somehow). > > Where the Charter says "The working group may decide to extend the current > milestones based on the new information and knowledge gained during working > on other documents listed in the initial milestones. Possible new documents > and milestones must still fit into the overall DMM charter scope as outlined > above. Milestones:[empty]" > > Please clarify that "initial milestones" is "RFC 4888, RFC 4889, > draft-ietf-dmm-best-practices-gap-analysis-08"). > > Alex > > > Le 08/10/2014 15:00, Jouni a écrit : >> >> Alex, >> >> Do you have a specific change to the text in mind? The charter text >> uses systematically "mobile host/router" to make sure mobile routers >> are not forgotten. However, charter also allows solutions that are >> not specifically tailored to mobile routers. >> >> Jouni >> > > > _______________________________________________ > dmm mailing list > [email protected] > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmm _______________________________________________ dmm mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmm
