Hi, I agree with Dennis and Brett's comments. I also prefer one version of doxia, with a parent pom. But if we want to go with two projects, we need two jira projects.
Cheers, Vincent 2007/8/21, Jason van Zyl <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > > On 21 Aug 07, at 6:05 PM 21 Aug 07, Brett Porter wrote: > > > To date, I have always been in favour of one trunk, and one version. > > > > I understand the need for a clear separate and for Doxia to be > > useful without the site tools, but I don't think separating the > > releases was the right way to do it. > > > > I use them completely separately. I barely touch the site generation > stuff in my integration. The site tools are completely layered upon > the core. If they are going to be clear and separate then they are > released separately and have separate trunks. I think people who > currently work on them have never used them for anything other then > the site plugin. It's also not hard to create another JIRA project. > > I don't particularly care if people want to glob them back together > but they are functionally separate. I can use the core without the > site tools, one is clearly and extension of the other. In this alpha > state changes in the site tools require changes in the core but that > should not be the case for very long. > > > - Brett > > > > On 22/08/2007, at 6:07 AM, Dennis Lundberg wrote: > > > >> Creating a separate thread for release questions... > >> > >> Do we have two releases in reality? On one hand we have > >> doxia:doxia (currently slated for alpha-9) and on the other we > >> have doxia:doxia-sitetools (currently slated for 1.0). Is > >> everybody OK with those versions? > >> > >> I am not. Having two different versions for these two will totally > >> mess up JIRA. Therefor I'd like to use 1.0-alpha-9 for both, this > >> time. If we want separate releases for them in the future, then we > >> need two separate projects for doxia and doxia-sitetools in JIRA. > >> > >> In order for the maven-site-plugin to be able to use the new > >> doxia:doxia we need to release doxia:doxia-sitetools. > >> > >> Are there any other questions regarding the release? > >> > >> -- > >> Dennis Lundberg > > Thanks, > > Jason > > ---------------------------------------------------------- > Jason van Zyl > Founder and PMC Chair, Apache Maven > jason at sonatype dot com > ---------------------------------------------------------- > > > >
