Ralph Glasstetter wrote:
>> Bother, I spoke too early!
>>
>> The first two of my edited TS files that lost their Chapter Marks in the
>> XML template under R107 indeed regained them under R108. The third
>> edited file still loses them under both.
> Very strange... do you use a project file and read that same file under all
> versions?
Yes.
> Could you show us such a project file (which contains all the set marks)
> and the log output you produced with it?
>
> I've not idea why the set chapter marks and the printed list should depend on
> the TS files used... if there is any relation then only indirectly comming
> from the order / type of marks and how you set them!
Sorry for the delay in coming back to you on this one. I had a big
transcription to DVD and purge of the PVR archive over the weekend, so
the original problematic video files were no more :-(.
The attached (new) problematic file shows the sort of experiment I was
carrying out. The first run (R108) shows an empty Chapter List and
only chapters="00:00:00.000" in the XML template. The second (R105 on
the same project file and data) shows the expected full Chapter List.
>> In all three cases, R105 displays the Chapter List and XML Chapter Marks
>> as expected.
>
> Hmmm,.... the funny thing is, that in r107 we fixed a bug concerning the
> chapterlist, which in the about 10 revisions before (so also in r105) did NOT
> work as (we!) expected.
>
> Might it be that you expect someting different from this list as we do?
> Or at least use the chapter marks in a different way as we do...
Primarily, I use each log file XML template (with its chapter list) to
build up a composite XML input file for dvdauthor to transcribe a series
of episodes to DVD. It's worked very well in the past with the dvbcut /
dvdauthor combination, so I was surprised to hit a snag.
Incidentally, there is a lot of jumping between 16:9 (coomercials) and
4:3 (feature) in this Soprano series; could this be of any relevance?
Best wishes .. and again many thanks.
--
David
$ dvbcut.108 1014_20071211000500.mpg
Analyzed transport stream, 0 bytes of initial data (IRC=-1)
PAT: found PMT at pid 270
PMT: found video stream at pid 590
PMT: found audio stream at pid 591
PMT: found audio stream at pid 592
PMT: can't handle subtitle stream at pid 593
$ cat 1014_20071211000500.dvbcut
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE dvbcut>
<dvbcut>
<mpgfile path="/home/david/Projects/videos/The
Sopranos/1014_20071211000500.mpg" />
<idxfile path="/home/david/Projects/videos/The
Sopranos/1014_20071211000500.idx" />
<start picture="12600" />
<stop picture="17492" />
<chapter picture="23628" />
<start picture="23628" />
<stop picture="43488" />
<chapter picture="49620" />
<start picture="49620" />
<stop picture="70496" />
<chapter picture="76620" />
<start picture="76620" />
<stop picture="116136" />
</dvbcut>
$ dvbcut.108 1014_20071211000500.dvbcut
Analyzed transport stream, 0 bytes of initial data (IRC=-1)
PAT: found PMT at pid 270
PMT: found video stream at pid 590
PMT: found audio stream at pid 591
PMT: found audio stream at pid 592
PMT: can't handle subtitle stream at pid 593
# output from R108 log file
1. Exporting 4892 pictures: 00:08:24.000/00 .. 00:11:39.680/00
Estimated mux rate: 0.47 MB/s
Recoding 1 pictures
Audio channel 1: starts 8.033 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 1: stops 0.033 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 1: delayed 0.000 milliseconds
Audio channel 2: starts 2.744 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 2: stops 5.256 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 2: delayed 0.000 milliseconds
2. Exporting 19860 pictures: 00:15:45.120/00 .. 00:28:59.520/00
Estimated mux rate: 0.40 MB/s
Recoding 2 pictures
Audio channel 1: starts 0.033 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 1: stops 0.033 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 1: delayed 8.000 milliseconds
Audio channel 2: starts 5.256 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 2: stops 5.256 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 2: delayed 8.000 milliseconds
3. Exporting 20876 pictures: 00:33:04.800/00 .. 00:46:59.840/00
Estimated mux rate: 0.42 MB/s
Recoding 1 pictures
Audio channel 1: starts 0.033 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 1: stops 7.967 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 1: delayed 8.000 milliseconds
Audio channel 2: starts 5.256 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 2: stops 10.744 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 2: delayed 8.000 milliseconds
4. Exporting 39516 pictures: 00:51:04.800/00 .. 01:17:25.440/00
Estimated mux rate: 0.43 MB/s
Recoding 2 pictures
Audio channel 1: starts 7.967 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 1: stops 7.967 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 1: delayed -8.000 milliseconds
Audio channel 2: starts 10.744 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 2: stops 10.744 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 2: delayed -8.000 milliseconds
Saved 85144 pictures (00:56:45.760)
Chapter list
00:00:00.000
Simple XML-file for dvdauthor with chapter marks
<dvdauthor dest="2-13">
<vmgm />
<titleset>
<titles>
<pgc>
<vob file="2-13.mpg" chapters="00:00:00.000" />
</pgc>
</titles>
</titleset>
</dvdauthor>
$ dvbcut.105 1014_20071211000500.dvbcut
Analyzed transport stream, 0 bytes of initial data (IRC=-1)
PAT: found PMT at pid 270
PMT: found video stream at pid 590
PMT: found audio stream at pid 591
PMT: found audio stream at pid 592
PMT: can't handle subtitle stream at pid 593
# output from R105 log file
1. Exporting 4892 pictures: 00:08:24.000/00 .. 00:11:39.680/00
Estimated mux rate: 0.47 MB/s
Recoding 1 pictures
Audio channel 1: starts 8.033 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 1: stops 0.033 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 1: delayed 0.000 milliseconds
Audio channel 2: starts 2.744 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 2: stops 5.256 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 2: delayed 0.000 milliseconds
2. Exporting 19860 pictures: 00:15:45.120/00 .. 00:28:59.520/00
Estimated mux rate: 0.40 MB/s
Recoding 2 pictures
Audio channel 1: starts 0.033 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 1: stops 0.033 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 1: delayed 8.000 milliseconds
Audio channel 2: starts 5.256 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 2: stops 5.256 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 2: delayed 8.000 milliseconds
3. Exporting 20876 pictures: 00:33:04.800/00 .. 00:46:59.840/00
Estimated mux rate: 0.42 MB/s
Recoding 1 pictures
Audio channel 1: starts 0.033 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 1: stops 7.967 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 1: delayed 8.000 milliseconds
Audio channel 2: starts 5.256 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 2: stops 10.744 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 2: delayed 8.000 milliseconds
4. Exporting 39516 pictures: 00:51:04.800/00 .. 01:17:25.440/00
Estimated mux rate: 0.43 MB/s
Recoding 2 pictures
Audio channel 1: starts 7.967 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 1: stops 7.967 milliseconds before video
Audio channel 1: delayed -8.000 milliseconds
Audio channel 2: starts 10.744 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 2: stops 10.744 milliseconds after video
Audio channel 2: delayed -8.000 milliseconds
Saved 85144 pictures (00:56:45.760)
Chapter list
00:00:00.000
00:03:15.680
00:16:30.080
00:30:25.120
Simple XML-file for dvdauthor with chapter marks
<dvdauthor dest="2-13_1">
<vmgm />
<titleset>
<titles>
<pgc>
<vob file="2-13_1.mpg"
chapters="00:00:00.000,00:03:15.680,00:16:30.080,00:30:25.120" />
</pgc>
</titles>
</titleset>
</dvdauthor>
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
SF.Net email is sponsored by:
Check out the new SourceForge.net Marketplace.
It's the best place to buy or sell services for
just about anything Open Source.
http://sourceforge.net/services/buy/index.php
_______________________________________________
DVBCUT-user mailing list
DVBCUT-user@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/dvbcut-user
