> On 20 Feb 2020, at 09.39, Sebastian Potthoff <[email protected]> > wrote: > > Hi, > > follow-up question: If I create a generic PythonBundle, like > "PyTorch-Extensions" what version number would one use? > > Is it allowed to skip the version? Otherwise I would think of something like > 2019a or 2019.01 or similar? (I'm creating it for the foss-2019a toolchain)
I have not authority here, so feel free to ignore me :-) I would choose a version number like YYYYMMDD, that way you can fix things and make a new release the next day. 2019a would look like a relation to the toolchains, and might confuse people. Jakob > > Sebastian > > On 20.02.20 08:55, Sebastian Potthoff wrote: >> Hi Terje, >> >> many thanks for your insights! This certainly helps a lot. Once I sorted >> everything out, I will definitely make a PR :) >> >> Sebastian >> >> On 19.02.20 21:28, Terje Kvernes wrote: >>> Hi Sebastian, >>> >>> Without claiming any divine authority on the matter, I would suggest >>> separating out googledownloader and plyfile into their own EasyConfigs, and >>> keeping the rest of the PyTorch-related extensions in a "PyTorch >>> extensions”-bundle. >>> >>> It is always a tricky question when to extend more “core” packages and when >>> to make external bundles, but I’ve certainly started to lean towards using >>> bundles more. This usually makes the core packages easier to update and >>> reduces the possible dependency collisions between different extensions, >>> leaving users to make informed choices (via conflicts when required) about >>> what to load. >>> >>> If possible, could you create pull requests via --new-pr for these >>> EasyConfigs? The documentation is fairly straight forward on >>> https://easybuild.readthedocs.io/en/latest/Integration_with_GitHub.html. I >>> know some of my users are looking for PyTorch extensions, so I (and >>> probably many others) would be happy to test and contribute to these >>> EasyConfigs. :-) >>> >>>> On 19 Feb 2020, at 12:57, Sebastian Potthoff <[email protected]> >>>> wrote: >>>> >>>> Hi, >>>> >>>> I have a question concerning PythonBundles/Packages in general and >>>> specifically to an extension of PyTorch: "PyTorch-Geometric". >>>> (https://github.com/rusty1s/pytorch_geometric) >>>> >>>> I created an EC PythonBundle including several PyTorch extension modules >>>> needed for PyTorch-Geometric. However my exts_list also inlcudes >>>> "googledrivedownloader" and "plyfile". Should these extensions better be >>>> installed by separate EasyConfig files? What's the preferred way? >>>> >>>> There already is a PyTorch PythonPackage EC. Instead of creating a new >>>> PythonBundle, should I update the existing EC and add the extensions to >>>> this file? And when do I use the PythonBundle instead of the PythonPackage >>>> EB? >>>> >>>> Many thanks for your help >>>> Sebastian >>>> >>> > -- > Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität (WWU) Münster > WWU IT > Sebastian Potthoff, M.Sc. (eScience/HPC) > Röntgenstraße 7-13, R.207/208 > 48149 Münster > Tel. +49 251 83-31640 > E-Mail: [email protected] > Website: www.uni-muenster.de/it > >
