Warren,

I've read this thread with some consternation as a soil scientist.  I  
know this may sound like recycling of styrofoam but it's really  
putting xenobiotics (highly recalcitrant synthetics) into the soil.   
I'm not really sure if it would meet your other goal either.  While  
quantitatively decreasing soil bulk density, as does soil organic  
matter (SOM) I doubt that it provides any of the other benefits of  
SOM.  Styrofoam is a closed cell material, so even with a high  
surface area (internally and externally) I doubt that soil solution  
or nutrients can interact with these surfaces to provide cation/anion  
exchange or enhance soil aeration as the cells are generally filled  
with a synthetic gas (previously these were CFCs).

Also, there is increasing evidence that plastics release synthetic  
compounds, the effects of some are known others unknown.  Moreover,  
organic chemistry of the SOM and plastics degradation are not well  
understood.

If you have any data or literature on these questions I would be very  
interested.  In lieu of any evidence of benefits/hazards I would  
strongly advise against the practice.

David

David M Bryant Ph D
University of New Hampshire
Environmental Education Program
Durham, NH 03824

[EMAIL PROTECTED]
978-356-1928



On Jan 23, 2006, at 2:44 PM, Warren W. Aney wrote:

> I hope to solve two problems:
> --recycling of styrofoam
> --improving the texture of of high clay content soils
>
> Warren Aney
> (503)246-8613
>
>   -----Original Message-----
>   From: Wayne Tyson [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>   Sent: Sunday, 22 January, 2006 22:51
>   To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [email protected]
>   Subject: Re: Birds and styrofoam pellets
>
>
>   What do you hope to accomplish, and what led you to do it?
>
>   WT
>
>   At 01:21 PM 1/22/2006, Warren W. Aney wrote:
>
>     I have been using small (<5 mm) styrofoam pellets as a soil  
> additive.
> Since
>     they tend to accumulate on the soil surface, these whitish  
> pellets might
>     easily be ingested by ground foraging birds.  I've done a quick  
> Google
>     search and found little information indicating whether or not this
> material
>     might be ingested or, if ingested, that it will have adverse  
> effects.
> Does
>     anyone have any information regarding this?
>
>     Warren Aney
>     (503)246-8613

Reply via email to