Perhaps I added confusion.

If your friend uses T-Online as an ISP, and wants to use Ekiga to do SIP 
with an ekiga.net account, this should work, for me - the connection 
requires STUN.

So forget using T-Online VOIP, they just happen to be the ISP in this 
case. should work fine.

here is my setup:

account                 ekiga.net
        registrar       ekiga.net
        user            field64
        password        XXXXXXX
        auth login      field64
        reg. timeout    3600

Preferences
        Network
                listen on       eth0 192.168.17.20
                Nat traversal STUN
                STUN Server     stun.ekiga.net

        SIP settings
                outbound proxy  BLANK
                forward ULR     sip:    (default)
                send DTMF       rfc2833 (default)

call [EMAIL PROTECTED], it works.

I can also disable STUN and use "Ip translation". I have 3 different 
routers, two have SIP AGLs, which means it keeps track of SIP sessions 
to PCs on the private side.

the 3rd is a netgear, I've configured the following NAT ports to my PC:
probably very similar to all home ADSL routers)

1         tonline_voip  ALLOW always    192.168.17.20   Any     Always
2         stun  ALLOW always    192.168.17.20   Any     Always  
3         IP    ALLOW always    192.168.17.20   Any     Always
Default         Yes     Any     BLOCK always    Any     Any     Never

Service Table
        #       Service Type    Ports
        1       SIP (TCP/UDP)   5060 - 5070
        2       stun (TCP/UDP)  3478 - 3479
        3       tonline_voip (TCP)      30000 - 30005

I'm no ekiga expert, but this certainly sounds like a router issue, or 
you need STUN.




> Here's an excerpt of a -d 4 session:
> 2008/03/02 12:10:03.093         0:05.251        Opal
> Listener:3974b98      Listen  Started listening thread on
> tcp$192.168.2.100:1720
> 2008/03/02 12:10:03.093         0:05.251        Opal
> Listener:3974b98      Listen  Waiting on socket accept on
> tcp$192.168.2.100:1720
> 2008/03/02 12:10:03.203         0:05.360        Opal
> Listener:39750f0      Listen  Started listening thread on
> udp$192.168.2.100:5060
> 2008/03/02 12:10:03.203         0:05.360        Opal
> Listener:39750f0      Listen  Waiting on UDP packet on
> udp$192.168.2.100:5060
> 2008/03/02 12:10:07.234         0:09.392        Opal
> Listener:39750f0      OpalUDP Pre-bound to interface: 192.168.2.100:5060
> 2008/03/02 12:10:07.234         0:09.393        Opal Listener:39750f0 SIP     
> Waiting
> for PDU on udp$0.0.0.0<if=udp$192.168.2.100:5060>
> 2008/03/02 12:10:07.234         0:09.393        Opal Listener:39750f0 SIP     
> PDU
> Received on udp$62.225.244.122:5060<if=udp$192.168.2.100:5060>
> SIP/2.0 401 Unauthorized
> CSeq: 541 REGISTER
> Via: SIP/2.0/UDP
> 192.168.2.100:5060;received=192.168.2.100;branch=z9hG4bKfe761a4434911d9be5dc7d3c56a759a2-14088588
> From: <sip:[EMAIL 
> PROTECTED]:5060>;tag=617263616479616E-1919468571-a8347dea-858167570
> Call-ID: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> To: <sip:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:5060>;tag=5652ecc6
> Content-Length: 0
> WWW-Authenticate: Digest algorithm=MD5,
> nonce="b629444af1e3cf48a71703e908517b6d24f502d66a847b032705f1f1f5fffc1a",
> opaque="b629444af1e3cf48a71703e908517b6d24f502d66a847b032705f1f1f5fffc1a",
> realm="tel.t-online.de"
> 
> 
> Where did t-online.de come from ???
> 
> 
> 
> Here's a snippet of an earlier session:
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.109         0:01.844        GMStunClient:03b4efc0 STUN    
> Error
> writing to server 0.0.0.0:3478 - WIN32 error 10049
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.109         0:01.845        GMStunClient:03b4efc0 STUN    
> Server
> 0.0.0.0:3478 unexpectedly went offline.
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.109         0:01.845        GMStunClient:03b4efc0 OPAL    
> STUN
> server "stun.ekiga.net" replies Unknown NAT, external IP 0.0.0.0
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.109         0:01.847        GMStunClient:03b4efc0 STUN    
> Error
> writing to server 0.0.0.0:3478 - WIN32 error 10049
> ...
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.296       
> 0:02.034      GMAccounts...t:03be13a8 OpalUDP Binding to interface:
> 192.168.2.100:3855
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.296         0:02.034      GMAccounts...t:03be13a8 SIP     
> Created
> transport udp$0.0.0.0<if=udp$192.168.2.100:3855>
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.296         0:02.035      GMAccounts...t:03be13a8 Opal    
> Could
> not find host : "ekiga.net"
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.296         0:02.035      GMAccounts...t:03be13a8 SIP     
> Could
> not connect to udp$ekiga.net:5060 -
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.296       
> 0:02.035      GMAccounts...t:03be13a8 Opal    Transport clean up on
> termination
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.296         0:02.036      GMAccounts...t:03be13a8 OpalUDP 
> Close
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.296         0:02.036      GMAccounts...t:03be13a8 Opal    
> Transport Close
> 2008/03/02 10:52:10.296         0:02.036      GMAccounts...t:03be13a8 SIP     
> Unable
> to create transport for registrar
> 2008/03/02 10:52:18.031         0:09.768        Opal
> Listener:3bd7540      OpalUDP Pre-bound to interface: 192.168.2.100:5060
> 2008/03/02 10:52:18.031         0:09.769        Opal Listener:3bd7540 SIP     
> Waiting
> for PDU on udp$0.0.0.0<if=udp$192.168.2.100:5060>
> 2008/03/02 10:52:18.031         0:09.769        Opal Listener:3bd7540 SIP     
> PDU
> Received on udp$217.0.132.118:5060<if=udp$192.168.2.100:5060>
> SIP/2.0 401 Unauthorized
> CSeq: 492 REGISTER
> Via: SIP/2.0/UDP
> 217.233.78.31:5060;received=217.233.78.31;branch=z9hG4bK6c4154930df06d7486c7e8c47ac8bc84
> From: <sip:[EMAIL 
> PROTECTED]:5060>;tag=617263616479616E-1919468571-a8347dea-858167570
> Call-ID: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> To: <sip:[EMAIL PROTECTED]:5060>;tag=5005a17b
> Content-Length: 0
> WWW-Authenticate: Digest algorithm=MD5,
> nonce="42534f9f0599375a5e7ab94005f920af7757d217c644f5be594b218eba6e710a",
> opaque="42534f9f0599375a5e7ab94005f920af7757d217c644f5be594b218eba6e710a",
> realm="tel.t-online.de"
> 
> Any ideas as to where I could try to look ?
> 

_______________________________________________
ekiga-list mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list

Reply via email to