kapetr wrote: > ---- Eugen Dedu wrote: > >> kapetr wrote: >>>>> Just little modification would make this perfect >>>>>>>> - see my post at this >>>>>> bug report. >>>> Does ekiga show ALWAYS symmetric nat with that router? >>>>>> Because >>>> sometimes I receive symmetric nat on my own router >>>>>> too, I think this >>>> appear in special conditions (I have just stopped >>>> ekiga >>>>>> or sommething >>>> like this). >>>> >>>> -- >>>> Eugen >>>> >>> Hello, >>> >>> Yes - Ekiga reports ALWAYS, it is symetric NAT. >>> >>> I have also run: >>> >>> root# stun stun.ekiga.net -v >>> >>> output is in attachment - unfortunately I don't understand >>> the output: >>>> -mapped IP same = 1 >>> -hairpin = 0 >>> -preserver port = 0 >>> >>> and I could find no documentation of it. >>> >>> But the point is - twinkle works behind also that >>> NAT modem, and Ekiga >>>> not - so I thing modification proposed (see my post >>> at https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ekiga/+bug/517580 >>>> ) would be positive. >>> With such modification I (and probably many others) >>> would be finally >>>> able to use Ekiga :-) >> Could you test with another two stun servers to see >> if if they return >> always symmetric nat? >> >> -- >> Eugen > > In attachment are 2 stun test outputs (stun2.txt and stun3.txt)- if they > mean the NAT is symmetric - I don't know.
Could you please test *with ekiga* those servers? You do that by modifying stun_server entry in .gconf/apps/ekiga/general/nat/%gconf.xml (or use gconf-editor). > But see also stun4.txt - the port in mappedAddr differs for 2 different > STUN servers- also it seems to be a symmetric NAT. > > BTW - Twinkle reports with pop-up warning also symmetric NAT. > > > Interesting is, that with Twinkle the echo test (500) works - of course: > the SIP server and called number (500) are on the same IP address. > The call to someone else would probably fail. > > But Ekiga client do not get answer for his INVITE request ?! So Ekiga > fails calling 500 behind symmetric NAT. -- Eugen _______________________________________________ ekiga-list mailing list [email protected] http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
