Andy,
You are dealing with an RS-232 communications protocol, which is only
point to point and not multipoint like Ethernet.
I have no idea how your "polling" device works, but with RS-232, there
is no polling, it is direct "handshaking" between 2 devices, a DTE and a
DCE. If handshaking is implemented, Data Terminal Ready, Data Set Ready
are exchanged, then Request to Send and the Clear To Send Response are
sent. That signalling protocol is normally used only by modems.
Most ham applications do not use those handshaking signals, but rely
only on Transmit Data and Receive Data to establish communications.
For RS-232 there MUST be only one transmitter - there can be multiple
receivers, but those devices (other than the main one, either the PC or
the KPA500) can be the transmitter. It takes some complex hardware
device to switch an RS-232 bus from one transmitter to another.
This is a hardware consideration and has nothing to do with software
such as OmniRig.
Consider the RS-232 voltage levels and you will see why there can be
only one transmitter on a line. The active level is between +3.5 volts
and +25 volts while the inactive level can be from -3.5 volts to -25 volts.
Think about what happens when you connect one device producing +25 volts
directly to the output of another device producing -25 volts! That is
why only one transmitter can be used on an RS-232 signal line.
There are several devices that can be used (such as the SteppIR
controller) in an RS-232 environment, but their configuration must be
set to only listen to the traffic on the main RS-232 communications
which is normally the PC and the transceiver.
The S-Box has the transmitters hardware disabled for all but one port -
that is how it allows multiple devices to listen in on the communications.
73,
Don W3FPR
On 2/11/2019 3:04 PM, Andy Durbin wrote:
"The Serial Box<https://bit.ly/S-BOX> (S-BOX) was specifically designed to make it
easy to connect multiple devices in parallel to any transceiver's serial port, including a PC,
KPA500, KAT500, KPA1500, SteppIR Controller, Kessler AT-Auto, Shackmaster SM-8, etc. "
My configuration requires one device to be the routine polling device but has
to allow for another device to break that polling interface and insert
different commands to the destination equipment.
E.g - 1. OmniRig polls my TS-590 and my TS-590/Elecraft interface listens to the
responses. When I want to set the TS-590 power, or initiate a TX Tune, my
TS-590/Elecraft interface disconnects OmniRig, attaches the local RS232 source, sends the
power command, then returns control to OmniRig. The supplemental commands are timed to
only be sent in the "window" where OmniRig is not sending a command. (It's
actually a bit more complicated than that because initiating a TX Tune first inhibits the
amplifier key line then, when key inhibit is confirmed, it initiates TX Tune with a
specific power setting, returns TS-590 to receive mode, waits until RX mode is
confirmed, then re-enables the amplifier key line.)
E.g -2. The KAT500 utility may be polling my KAT500 but I disconnect it and send the
KAT500 commands to change L, C, bypass, antenna side, etc. Again this is is done without
disrupting KAT500 utility polling as the commands are only sent in the "window"
between the utility polls. Depending on an option setting the TS-590/Elecraft interface
can be the primary KAT500 polling device and the utility is not needed.
Examples 1 and 2 were implemented a while ago and are mature and reliable. The
next step is to integrate the KPA500 so OPER/STBY are fully integrated in my
power control scheme.
______________________________________________________________
Elecraft mailing list
Home: http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/elecraft
Help: http://mailman.qth.net/mmfaq.htm
Post: mailto:[email protected]
This list hosted by: http://www.qsl.net
Please help support this email list: http://www.qsl.net/donate.html
Message delivered to [email protected]
