Mike, You wrote (Sun.May22):
Critics of IRV haven't said that IRV is evil. We've only said that IRV isn't a significant reform or a significant improvement over Plurality.
The part after "We've only said that.." logically implies that either: (1) "IRV is evil" , or (2) "Plurality isn't evil, or is only slightly evil". Let's just say that I was paraphrasing the clearly implied message. Chris Benham ---- Election-methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
