Hi Forest, --- En date de : Sam 22.5.10, fsimmons at pcc.edu <fsimmons at pcc.edu> a écrit : > The alternative X is used as the approval cutoff. On > some of the ballots the > cutoff is considered excluded (not including X as approved) > but on just enough > ballots to make X the approval winner, the cutoff is > considered inclusive (so on > these ballots X is approved). > > The "reluctance" of ballot B in approving X is the > difference between the > maxrange value and the rating given to alternative X by > ballot B. > > Elect the alternative X with the least possible reluctance > total.
I don't understand how you determine which ballots approve X. Is it random, or irrelevant? Or do you have to find the selection which will minimize reluctance to electing X? Kevin Forest replies: Yes, the selection that minimizes reluctance. That’s why I put the word “possible” in the phrase, “minimum possible reluctance.” Start by approving X on all of the ballots with zero reluctance for X, then move on to the ballots that have a reluctance of one, etc. until there is enough approval for X to overcome the approval for the candidates that are preferred over X . ---- Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
