I guess (assuming I am allowed to duplicate ratings) I would call Additive Approval Voting an E (if we are using ABCDEF) - I like it better than DAT and IRAV, but less well than all the others. If E is not allowed, I guess flip a coin as to whether it gets a D or F.
On a side note, it's interesting how having this vote makes me more directly aware of the voting system than thinking abstractly about it. -Benn Grant eFix Computer Consulting <mailto:[email protected]> [email protected] 603.283.6601 From: Jameson Quinn [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, June 17, 2013 3:04 PM To: Benjamin Grant Cc: Abd ul-Rahman Lomax; [email protected]; election-methods Subject: Re: [EM] [CES #8791] Upper-Bucklin naming (was: Median systems, branding....) New running tally. Current voting tallies in parentheses, ordered JQ/AL/RB/AJ/DSH/BG. Note the new option for Additive Approval Voting, which could be a winner if Abd, Andy, and Ben like it enough. Current contenders for best are in bold. Instant Runoff Approval Voting: (B/A/F/C/F/F) Median C/F. Descending Approval Threshold Voting: (A/B-/B/C/C/F) Median B-/C. Majority Approval Voting: (A/?/C/A/A/D) Median A/C Majority Support Voting: (B/?/C/A/C/D) Median C Cumulative Approval Voting: (A/?/B/?/D/A) Median B/D Additive Approval Voting: (B/?/B/?/B/?) Median B/? Cumulative Support Voting: (A/?/B/?/F/C) Median C/? Jameson
---- Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
