Hi overthere. Am Mittwoch, den 03.10.2007, 12:26 +0000 schrieb Jonas Borgström: > True, it's up to you to decide if the benefits are enough to add an > additional dependency. As I said before I just wanted to make sure you > were aware of Babel and the additional benefits it provides compared to > the gettext+locale python modules.
Okay. We are aware of the project and as you already said, it wouldn't make that much work for us to change it. But before I NEED to know, if it is able to use the 3-letter code (because as far as I can see, there is only the LANG-Code thing). But let's get to the more interesting part: > Well, I have no idea what the gettext language code would be for > prussian, but I'm sure there is one. The language_TERRITORY convention > used by GNU gettext does not always use 2-letter codes (ISO-639). For > more rarely used languages a 3-letter code (ISO-639-2) code is used > instead. So as far as I can tell this convention also covers all > languages. Another important detail is that this convention also allows > a TERRITORY to be specified, which is very important to be able to > determine which locale data to use. As you can simply see here: http://www.sil.org/iso639-3/codes.asp?order=reference_name&letter=p there is no other language-code than the one specified in ISO-639-3 for prussian. The 3-Letter-codes which are used in language_territory are specified in ISO-639-2. Just take a look at that page and you'll see, that there are big differences between these different ISOs. But maybe this simple counter can convince you: ISO-639-1 has about 180 codes ISO-639-2 has about 450 codes ISO-639-3 has about 6900 codes > http://www.gnu.org/software/gettext/manual/html_node/Language-Codes.html > Another thing. Wouldn't the use of 3-letter codes force you to have to > maintain some kind of translation table between 3-letter codes and the > language_TERRITORY convention used by the operating system in order to > set the locale and to detect the locale and language used by the > operating system? Yes. I also don't like that, too. Of course. But we only do this for the main-languages. Because we can't figure out the best iso-3 code from the lang_territory code, we only use the first 'lang' part and try to figure out, what the equal one in iso-3 is. I guess. That was a good argument. I've already thought, that there are a lot of discussions about this. That is absolutely normal because this ISO is really jung (Feb 07) but I'm sure that is going to be the one for us and the one for the future use. So my question again: is babel able to handle the 3-letter codes? Benjamin Good links: http://www.sil.org/iso639-3/codes.asp http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_639 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_639
