James, You are right on the point about distinguishing stable and experimental releases - this seems quite important, given recent events. Any volunteers for this?
Ideally we should also have some kind of automatic basic testing as well, to prevent obvious breakages. Volunteers? There are fragments lying around. But I disagree (still) about "why save people 10 mins of compiling etc" - many existing and potential users like things to work out of the box (think professors and undergraduates...). It's also faster for me to write a script to compile and bundle stuff, than it is to explain in detail how to compile. Note there is only one cron job, which makes the Solaris version from clean; then it bundles the most recent linux and windows binaries into relevant packages. (We could also make the Linux binary from scratch - volunteers?) And I don't see how/why adding relatively minor platforms (outside the four we've got) means we shouldn't bother with automating the main platforms. That doesn't seem sensible. What do you mean by "sensible installer" though? The windows and unix packages (should) work by a single entry point which sets all relevant flags. What more do we need? Another one for the "implementors mtg"? Paul
