I agree..
This tool is a great idea but I think it need some work. I took the test
a bunch of times and among other things got WAY to many Linspire
reccomendations ~shivvver ~.
It also does not ask about support. Especialy for a new users or a
business system you may want to use something you can buy support on in
an emergency.
Mark Ellister
T. Joseph CARTER wrote:
On Thu, Jan 12, 2006 at 09:11:25AM -0800, Bob Miller wrote:
Going with basic criteria (somewhere between "desktop user" and
experienced) I ended up with Ubuntu, Kubuntu, Suse, Debian.
Yeah, I also got four recommendations.
I like that it gives a short list instead of just saying "You are a
Mandriva user."
I don't know, it seems to be very full of stereotypical responses. For
example, it recommends Debian to me based solely on the answer to the
question of my experience level being advanced or expert. If I tell it
advanced, it offers me just Ubuntu. Debian's not all that high on the
expertise requirement scale, though I know it is reputed to be preferred
by the best and brightest.
Bugs (which have been fixed) notwithstanding, the install process of
Debian that is "so hard" is the one of Ubuntu that is "so easy". They
also don't ask someone of high skill level how much screwing-with-it they
want to do. Debian is disqualified by the fact that I have about zero
interest in sitting down to carefully fine-tune a kernel config for my
custom hardware setup. There's just no advantage to doing that anymore
that offsets the time it takes for me to configure and maintain it.
Debian technically doesn't require that even, it's just that Ubuntu's
kernels tend to have more desktop-class-hardware support included by
default whereas Debian default kernels are generally more workstation
oriented. Both have basics like sound drivers for modern PCI sound chips
and the like.
I am not surprised that it basically leads me to Ubuntu though, given my
preference for anything-but-rpm. I came to the same conclusion.
_______________________________________________
EUGLUG mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.euglug.org/mailman/listinfo/euglug
