Birgitt - Kudos for all of the wonderful guidance! I particularly agree that a Code of Conduct beyond the Law of Two Feet is a distraction. Patrice - if people want a code of conduct, I suggest providing some language around the Law of Two Feet. At heart, the Law of Two Feet is an invitation to take responsibility for what you love. I find people are quite willing to work through their differences when connecting around something that matters to them.
You can speak to the Law of Two Feet as a foot of passion and a foot of responsibility. With passion, you may have a good time or yell a lot but not much gets done. With responsibility, things may get done but meaning is missing. Together, passion and responsibility lead to important things happening. You can speak to the Law of Two Feet as guidance to move from a group if you are not learning, contributing, having a good time, or need to cool off. It is also guidance to stand for what you believe in. Whatever moves you. I find the Law of Two Feet and the principles that emerge from it create a welcoming space, where people feel they can show up authentically, express themselves, and connect with others. Those conditions send a message to those present that they belong. Because that combination — I can be myself and belong — violence just doesn’t happen. I have been in groups where no doubt many people carried weapons. In using Open Space since 1996, I have never seen violence. On another subject, I believe Patrice said they have 50 breakout spaces. That means over the several days they can handle way more than 50 topics. Like you, Birgitt, my experience is the number of sessions per group size drops as the group gets larger. My assumption has been that that is because someone else posts something similar to what they were thinking of. Different from you, I don’t think I’ve ever seen a group of 100 post 60-80 topics! I tend to estimate 1/3 of people post something in a group of 100. As an example, the session I just did in Philadelphia had 120 people with one day in Open Space. We had about 30 topics announced and after some combining, 25 sessions held. (Notes are here <https://journalismthatmatters.org/engagingemergence/session-notes/>.) By the time there are 1,000 people, it is more like 200 sessions — about 20% of participants. I find fewer people post a session in an online OS. I don’t know why that is the case. I did a 2-day, 3 hours/per day online OS in 2021 — during the pandemic — with 350 people. Largely because of the limits of 100 people in a Google-doc, which we used for notes, we split into three cohorts. The way we did it was to open with everyone in one Zoom space to do the welcome, including speaking to the purpose and the OS principles and law. Then we asked people to move to one of three spaces to announce and post topics. We split them loosely by last name (A-F, G-M, O-Z+). By loosely, we let people know that if they were there with a friend or weren’t comfortable with technology, they were welcome to go where it was best for them. We created a landing page with the Zoom links and links to the three agenda walls so that people could move to any session they wanted. We came back together as a whole group for evening news. We had a process host and a tech host for each of the three Zoom spaces. Our team did a walkthrough beforehand to work through anything we hadn’t anticipated. It all was incredibly smooth. We considered QiqoChat, which I agree is a terrific platform for support beyond just the event. Because we were dealing with a low threshold for tech skills, we opted for Zoom, which we figured they had used before and Google Docs. And we set them up in Groups.io <http://groups.io/> for ongoing connection. The session notes are all in this website: https://reimaginingbookstores.org/. Patrice, I hope some of this is useful to you. Do let us know how things go. Warmly, Peggy > On Oct 10, 2023, at 11:40 AM, Birgitt Williams via OSList > <[email protected]> wrote: > > Hi Patrice, > I've looked through the website. Love what you say (and the graphic) about > OST. I understand you have facilitated a number of OST events in the past and > that your reach out for support is that this one is for a larger group than > you have previously worked with...and that it is online. Probably you have > past experience with offering OST online. Online certainly requires > additional skills, planning. > > I find that the OST format, exactly as outlined in Harrison's Open Space: a > User's Guide, is the best formula to tap into the field of infinite > possibilities. I believe that underpinning the field of possibilities is the > field of love. Making adjustments to the OST format, adding things, has an > effect on accessing that field of love. I have a mantra for myself of "don't > put up blocks to love" when I am preparing for my OST meetings. > > With larger groups in an online environment, I prefer to use Qiqochat because > of the added features that I value. You are fortunate that your husband is > your tech guru and thus the risk of technology problems is greatly reduced. > > With larger groups online, I have looked at the dynamics of people posting > topics and fully participating. In my experience, voices get silenced (by > personal choice) when there are a lot of people. I find that about 100 people > in the group, maybe less, has more people involved in posting topics. A group > of 100 might post 60-80 topics. For this reason, I prefer to have concurrent > OST meetings with about 100 in a zoom room, having the opening, posting > topics. They can all be part of the same summit. Then in each zoom room of > posted topics, people do head off to break out rooms. With less people, > greater and hopefully lasting connections get made. If I read your > information correctly, you are anticipating 50 topics. With 1000 people, > there should be many more than that. It may be the least likely topic that > makes the biggest difference. > > I go back to Peggy's advice about the importance of a clear and compelling > purpose (theme) for the meeting. If you get that right, the rest sorts itself > out within the simple structure offered by OST. I read through the website, > and couldn't find the specific purpose (theme) for your OST summit. Examples > of themes are "issues and opportunities for freedom of religion and beliefs > for youth"; "opportunities gained from our diversity to strengthen freedom of > religion and beliefs for youth"; and the one that I think is most suitable in > view of your desire to create a movement is "issues and opportunities for > developing and sustaining a movement for religion and beliefs for youth". It > is important to know what your central attractor field is, what people are > being invited to. > > > > I am particularly attracted to OST events that are intended to make a change > in the future. I have studied the outcomes of OST events for some decades > now, those that have long lasting effects, and those that might have those > effects but they are not visible. I am less interested personally, in > evaluating an event based on the wonderful comments that participants always > make at the end of an OST in the closing circle. This is a bias I have. What > are people saying, what matters to them, four months after the OST event? If > set up well, that long term effect is much more likely. > > Thank you for asking for suggestions. I have offered what I have. I wish you > great success. > Warmly, > Birgitt > > > > > > Birgitt Williams > Senior consultant-author-mentor to leaders and consultants > Specialist in organizational and systemic transformation, leadership > development, and the benefits of nourishing a culture of leadership. > www.dalarinternational.com <http://www.dalarinternational.com/> > > Upcoming Workshops > Whole Person Process Facilitation | September 20, 21, 27 & 28, 2023 | Online > Individual Health and Balance | November 24, December 1, 8 & 15, 2023 | Online > Strategic Planning the Genuine Contact Way | January 8-13, 2024 | Online > > >> Learn More & Register > >> <http://www.dalarinternational.com/upcoming-workshops/> for any of these > >> workshops here. > > > > > > > 16 Sunny Acres Dr., Etowah, North Carolina, USA 28729 > Phone: 01-919-522-7750 > Like us on Facebook > <https://dalarinternational.us1.list-manage.com/track/click?u=35ed818c946a88ba7344da05f&id=6677c35b38&e=e7zyhHfiqG> > > Connect on LinkedIn > <https://dalarinternational.us1.list-manage.com/track/click?u=35ed818c946a88ba7344da05f&id=c26173f86b&e=e7zyhHfiqG> > > > > On Mon, Oct 9, 2023 at 10:45 PM Patrice Pederson <[email protected] > <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: >> Wow. I so appreciate all of the thought and consideration that you Birgitt >> and others have given to this! What an incredible community!! >> >> As for the Code of Conduct, I absolutely love everything you wrote Birgitt. >> The phrase "safe spaces" is actually a bit triggering to me, because I >> actually think that safety and growth are juxtaposed. And at the same time, >> while this event is my baby, I have a large planning committee for whom this >> event feels extremely radical. One of our partners is an inter-governmental >> body >> <https://www.state.gov/international-religious-freedom-or-belief-alliance/> >> comprised of 43 nations. Moreover, we have just pivoted from a one-to-three >> invitation method, to promoting the event publicly on social media. So an >> application to participate and the code of conduct are the only guardrails >> we have for my partners to not feel completely out of control. >> >> But we haven't yet nailed down the exact content of the code, so I am *very* >> open to suggestions. Our seed document (which is used by the International >> Religious Freedom Roundtable) was six single-spaced pages long with >> addendums! But in our last meeting we agreed that ours should be no more >> than five memorable bullet points. Basically, I want the participants to >> realize, in advance, that literally every single person there is going to >> disagree with them about something, and most of them are going to disagree >> with their most deeply held personal beliefs, and that's the whole point. >> Even in the previously mentioned Roundtable with all of the rules, fights >> break out semi-regularly--and this is among adults who work in this field >> professionally! The law of two feet is a great way to frame it. At the >> Roundtable we say that "we work on an opt-in basis" (ie, if you don't agree >> with someone, just don't support their initiative), and yet still with the >> fights. >> >> Bottom line, we need to have something, but I want to frame it with a lens >> of personal responsibility--both about giving and receiving offense. Very >> open to suggestions on wording here. >> >> As for your other comments, this is exactly what we are trying to do. I am >> always saying "we are building a movement, not just a meeting." We already >> launched a secure chat platform for participants to communicate before, >> during, and after the event. We have and are massively upgrading a resources >> directory for jobs, internships, other events, and trainings that people can >> participate in after. And we have various avenues for ongoing support of >> initiatives that either spring from or develop through the event. This is >> the part that I have given 1,000x more thought to than the actual event >> (which is perhaps why I may be making mistakes like having everyone in one >> room). >> >> But I'm not sure that I understand what you mean by all one room actually. >> We'd all be in the same room for the opening "circle," but then after that >> in 50 breakout rooms. What am I missing? >> >> As for tech support, we are recruiting volunteers to help with that--more at >> the beginning while we get things nailed down, and then we'll have small >> backup teams in Manilla/Bangkok, Erbil/Sri Jayawardenepura Kotte, and >> London/Lagos. My husband is a tech genius, and he and I will both be online >> for the first 15 hours, and then when he sleeps we have one other technical >> member of the planning committee who will be on duty, and then while I sleep >> the lovely Maria from above will facilitate from Spain. Either my husband or >> I will be online the whole time. >> >> I am still very much figuring out what facilitation will look like for this >> event, and I am sure that Maria will know a lot about that, but I am very >> open to suggestions on that as well! >> >> I'm attaching our Instagram campaign which we are launching tonight (late >> yes, but like I mentioned we recently pivoted invitation strategies). And >> for more information, our website is pretty good, https://forbsfuture.org/ >> >> I'm open to any and all other suggestions! >> >> Thank you! >> Patrice >> >> On Mon, Oct 9, 2023 at 3:41 PM Birgitt Williams via OSList >> <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: >>> Hi Patrice, >>> I have followed the thread about your 24 hour summit using Open Space >>> Technology as your method. I'll offer my perspective. >>> >>> Ditch the Code of Conduct--it doesn't belong in an OST meeting. It is >>> usually counter-productive in any participatory meeting as it closes the >>> space. Instead, include something in your opening that emphasizes that it >>> is up to each person to see to their own safety within the meeting. If they >>> are not learning something, nor contributing, use the Law of Two Feet (Law >>> of Mobility) to be somewhere that they are contributing, are learning. You >>> could include that in this meeting method, self-leadership is expected and >>> the Law of Two Feet applies if a person isn't feeling safe in a particular >>> topic group. People are capable of looking after their own safety with the >>> Law of Two Feet. In my experience, a facilitator cannot guarantee safe >>> space for anyone. As soon as two people are together, there is no guarantee >>> of safe space. The Law of Two Feet places the responsibility for feeling >>> safe, with the person themselves. >>> >>> You still have time to create a good wrap around for your OST-Rather than >>> planning for it as an event, plan for it to be more than that. If it were >>> me setting out to do what you are doing, I would talk to Lucas Cioffi >>> <http://[email protected]/> at QiqoChat. He has a wonderful product that >>> includes a wrap around the OST meeting. He can set up a garden for >>> butterflies and bumblebees to find each other. His product can be organized >>> for people to stay connected, have chats, keep adding to their topics, and >>> so much more. It is my assumption that you want to create something that >>> makes the greatest difference possible, and not limit the outcomes >>> unnecessarily. Lucas can help you think this through. >>> >>> Why all the people in one OST room? - I am wondering what you want to >>> accomplish by doing so. Why not have a few OST rooms available with >>> separate meetings of the summit taking place simulteneously ie 60-100 >>> people per room. The set up you are creating all depends on what you are >>> setting out to accomplish. Please do share. I don't think you have yet >>> shared the invitation that people have been sent. I would like to see what >>> they are being invited to. >>> >>> Technology - I see you asking for a co-facilitator for part of what you are >>> doing with this OST. How are you providing the tech support as well as the >>> facilitation support? We usually have some people responsible for the tech >>> support and others responsible for the facilitation. What have you got >>> sorted? >>> >>> From what I have seen you post, you have your arms around an event with a >>> lot of potential to create positive outcomes for the participants and in >>> the world. I am not sure, from what I have read, that you are making the >>> most of your opportunity for longer term outcomes...something sustainable, >>> not just an event. >>> >>> Please tell us more about your behind the scenes thinking. >>> >>> Warmly, >>> Birgitt >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> Birgitt Williams >>> Senior consultant-author-mentor to leaders and consultants >>> Specialist in organizational and systemic transformation, leadership >>> development, and the benefits of nourishing a culture of leadership. >>> www.dalarinternational.com <http://www.dalarinternational.com/> >>> >>> Upcoming Workshops >>> Whole Person Process Facilitation | September 20, 21, 27 & 28, 2023 | Online >>> Individual Health and Balance | November 24, December 1, 8 & 15, 2023 | >>> Online >>> Strategic Planning the Genuine Contact Way | January 8-13, 2024 | Online >>> >>> >> Learn More & Register >>> >> <http://www.dalarinternational.com/upcoming-workshops/> for any of these >>> >> workshops here. >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> 16 Sunny Acres Dr., Etowah, North Carolina, USA 28729 >>> Phone: 01-919-522-7750 >>> Like us on Facebook >>> <https://dalarinternational.us1.list-manage.com/track/click?u=35ed818c946a88ba7344da05f&id=6677c35b38&e=e7zyhHfiqG> >>> >>> Connect on LinkedIn >>> <https://dalarinternational.us1.list-manage.com/track/click?u=35ed818c946a88ba7344da05f&id=c26173f86b&e=e7zyhHfiqG> >>> >>> >>> >>> On Mon, Oct 9, 2023 at 12:08 AM Patrice Pederson via OSList >>> <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: >>>> Yes we are working on a Code of Conduct that everyone must agree to in >>>> advance. For this event that could get serious. >>>> >>>> So, I need even more help. I had someone who was going to be able to take >>>> over facilitating while I sleep for a few hours who was perfect. She has >>>> been on my planning committee for all of these months, so she knows all of >>>> the things. She was actually trained by Harrison Owen in OST. And she >>>> lives on the other side of the planet from me. >>>> >>>> But she lives in Israel and her whole world is in chaos now. And we're 11 >>>> days out from the event. Oh yeah, and I have no budget to hire anyone. >>>> >>>> Is there anyone out there who would be willing to step in sometime between >>>> 11pm-7am PDT on the morning of the 20th? I have a baby so I don't need >>>> much sleep. But I'll want some shut-eye to be sharp for the closing >>>> circle. >>>> >>>> Thanks! >>>> Patrice >>>> >>>> On Sun, Oct 8, 2023 at 7:14 AM Funda Oral via OSList <[email protected] >>>> <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: >>>>> Dear Patrice, >>>>> >>>>> This is not insane at all. Thanks for taking responsibility to bring up >>>>> such a crucial discussion and organizing this event. >>>>> >>>>> I took part in the following 24 hours virtual event in 2022 and i have >>>>> participated in several preparatory meetings before the actual event. >>>>> >>>>> Future of Work 24 Hours 2022 — Unimagined Possibilities >>>>> https://qiqochat.com/e/2022fow24hrs >>>>> >>>>> I will be happy to share my experiences with you. >>>>> >>>>> Lucas Cioffi, the creator of QiqoChat, is very experienced about various >>>>> virtual open space meetings. >>>>> >>>>> In addition, in your case, I would mention a few "safe space" rules in >>>>> addition to OST principles: Respectful language, no stereotypes and >>>>> prejudices, no mockery,don't exclude, don't embarrass, no gossip, no >>>>> discriminatory jokes,no sexualised language, fast in encouragement and >>>>> appreciation, slow in criticism, Take as much time to listen as to talk. >>>>> >>>>> Good Luck, >>>>> Funda Oral >>>>> https://sites.google.com/view/fundaoraltoussaint/main-page?authuser=0 >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> Le ven. 6 oct. 2023 à 08:23, Patrice Pederson via OSList >>>>> <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> a écrit : >>>>>> Hello everyone! >>>>>> >>>>>> I'm a first time poster. I asked a couple questions in a facebook group >>>>>> and was told about this group. I do have a couple of specific questions, >>>>>> but honestly I mostly need a little reassurance that what I am >>>>>> attempting to do is not completely insane. And if it is, then maybe some >>>>>> ideas for how to mitigate the damage? >>>>>> >>>>>> I've committed to literally everyone in my professional field to host a >>>>>> Global Youth Summit for Freedom of Religion or Belief. >>>>>> <http://email.mail.firstfreedomfoundation.org/c/eJwcybFqwzAQANCvOW0NJ8mxo0GDa2MChYbQ0KFLsa27yMWuhKQY-velXd7ynGXlWAqysjb1sdEKpfCWjHGIyPNELGVFrtbj3NDEI56ITigW27Wv55d0MbED3d-kP39-bLs2T7OMPl6PzdC3oJ5v5fL21b9XZucppLa7QoXbuKyH-79z2MRqfSkxg25BDaAGDmnK_CiPRIeQ7qAGkSztlH7CN0GFIa9LLn_1GwAA___SYTt7> >>>>>> I've got a few dozen countries co-sponsoring the thing as well as >>>>>> several NGOs. It's something I have had on the backburner for years, >>>>>> until the UK Prime Minister's Special Envoy heard about it, lit a fire >>>>>> under me, and now it is spreading like wildfire and I can hardly keep >>>>>> up. >>>>>> >>>>>> So here are the questions: >>>>>> 1) So far we have young people from around 65 countries registered. >>>>>> Instead of doing three eight hour days, I decided to do one 24 (well 25 >>>>>> really) hour day so that people can participate from wherever they are >>>>>> in the world--during work, before or after school or work, etc. I >>>>>> genuinely have no idea when people will participate or for how long, and >>>>>> I know that this violates one of the rules of Open Space which is that >>>>>> it is no good to pop in and out. But for this purpose I really don't see >>>>>> an alternative. >>>>>> >>>>>> So, insane? Any way to mitigate the damage? I did schedule the Opening >>>>>> Circle for a time when people should at least be awake from LA to >>>>>> Bangkok (and we don't have many Pacific Islanders registered yet >>>>>> anyway). And for those who are working we will record that event for >>>>>> later consumption. >>>>>> >>>>>> 2) Does anyone have experience with multilingual Open Space events? My >>>>>> first instinct was that everyone needs to speak English. But the result >>>>>> is that we have only three participants from Latin America. So we are a >>>>>> "global" summit minus one entire continent. So then my second thought is >>>>>> that, if we could get like 50 people, with enough bilingual people to >>>>>> cross-pollinate, then we could have a sort of an event within an event. >>>>>> >>>>>> Again, crazy? Or totally fine because Open Space is Open? >>>>>> >>>>>> Finally, this event is already going to be wild. We have a ton of >>>>>> Nigerians coming, many of whom have personally seen their friends and >>>>>> family members stabbed, burned, disappeared, etc., by Islamists. And >>>>>> then we have Muslims whose friends and families are getting lynched by >>>>>> Hindus in India, or genocided in Burma and China, and Hindus who are >>>>>> being persecuted in Pakistan, and LGBTQ youth who are getting bullied by >>>>>> so-called Christians, etc. etc. etc. Basically, everyone is a victim >>>>>> somewhere, and everyone is an aggressor somewhere, and I'm getting them >>>>>> all together in one big virtual room with 50+ breakout sessions and just >>>>>> one me. >>>>>> >>>>>> So, is co-facilitation a possibility? Would anybody be interested? Also, >>>>>> I do need to sleep at some point. We're going to need mechanisms to >>>>>> enforce a code of conduct (nonviolence at a minimum), but I think that I >>>>>> shouldn't be the one to enforce it because I need to hold the space, >>>>>> yes? >>>>>> >>>>>> Basically I could just really use some support, and I read that this >>>>>> group is good for that. It has been a minute since grad school when I >>>>>> studied all of this stuff. And while I have taken liberties with the OST >>>>>> model in the past, this time I'm worried that I might have gone too far. >>>>>> >>>>>> Thanks for any words. >>>>>> >>>>>> Patrice >>>>>> OSList mailing list -- [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> >>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] >>>>>> <mailto:[email protected]> >>>>>> See the archives here: >>>>>> https://oslist.org/empathy/list/everyone.oslist.org >>>>> OSList mailing list -- [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> >>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] >>>>> <mailto:[email protected]> >>>>> See the archives here: https://oslist.org/empathy/list/everyone.oslist.org >>>> OSList mailing list -- [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> >>>> To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] >>>> <mailto:[email protected]> >>>> See the archives here: https://oslist.org/empathy/list/everyone.oslist.org >>> OSList mailing list -- [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> >>> To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] >>> <mailto:[email protected]> >>> See the archives here: https://oslist.org/empathy/list/everyone.oslist.org > OSList mailing list -- [email protected] > To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] > See the archives here: https://oslist.org/empathy/list/everyone.oslist.org
OSList mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] See the archives here: https://oslist.org/empathy/list/everyone.oslist.org
