John Mikes writes (quoting Brent Meeker):

> > Well that's the question isn't it.  Is there
> > something besides memories and personality that
> > makes you you...
> But how much do we (already???) know about our
> memories 
> which for sure is a concoction with our personality,
> of which we just as well know very little.
> Different people have different memories of the same
> event (not only the biased eyewitnesses). \
> Never ask a psych-professional because he may be just
> as biased in "knowing his profession" as you are with
> yours. (Stathis, no hard feelings, please, you have
> disclosed a lot of thinking beyond your learned
> topics) 
> We have a crude fractional picture of who we are and
> what we know (or don't) and "memory" is a big mystery.
> Bigger only is "personality". 

We can't be sure that our memories are accurate. This puts us in a similar 
position when we consider our own past as when we consider someone else's past: 
we think that we know what it was like to be five years old, but our brains may 
have changed so much in the intervening years that this recollection may be 
little more vivid or accurate than if we were imagining what someone else's 
childhood was like after reading a book about it. There is no reason why every 
other mental quality, including the sense of identity, might not also change 
greatly over decades, with the only reason we think we remain the same person 
being that this change is gradual.

Stathis Papaioannou
Try where your online world comes together - with news, sports, 
weather, and much more.
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For more options, visit this group at

Reply via email to