On Tue, 2010-07-13 at 17:48 +0100, David Woodhouse wrote: > On Tue, 2010-07-13 at 12:01 -0430, Patrick O'Callaghan wrote: > > When the message being replied to is *not* a list message (i.e. the > > List-* headers -- specifically List-Post -- are not present), then > > everything works as now, except that Reply To List (Ctrl-L) has the same > > effect as Reply To All (Shift-Ctrl-R). > > > > When List-Post is present, Ctrl-L has the same effect as currently, i.e. > > it replies to the List-Post address only. > > That can be rephrased as simply "enable the Reply-to-list option even > when not looking at a list message". Or, in 'diff -up' form:
Sure, I was trying to be very explicit. [...] > But if you want a key-combo which does this "reply to all or list" > thing, then I suspect you'd do better to use Ctrl-Shift-R and the patch > in https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=624204#c8 for that. That's different. Consider a list message with a CC line. Reply To List replies only to the list. Reply To All replies also to the CC recipients. Both are valid options. > Otherwise we'll get users being confused that the 'Reply to list' menu > item is enabled even on non-list messages. The text can change to Reply To All, keeping the shortcut. Sure, that gives two shortcuts for the same action (Ctrl-L and Shift-Control-R) but it wouldn't be the first time, e.g. in mail mode both Ctrl-N and Shift-Control-M bring up the new message composer. > > In all cases, Reply To Sender (Ctrl-R) works exactly as now. > > > > A new Reply To Author action (no shortcut) replies only to the message > > originator, even when the message is from a munged list. Munged lists > > are detected by comparing the Reply-To header with the List-Post header > > (note that the former is an address while the latter is a URI). If they > > don't match, do the same as Ctrl-R. If they do match, ignore Reply-To > > and do the same as Ctrl-R. > > That's a really good idea, and I'd probably make an option for the > "normal" reply to do that. After all, that's what the normal reply > option is *supposed* to do. Hmm, a "de-munging" MUA. I'll reserve judgment on that one :-) poc _______________________________________________ evolution-list mailing list [email protected] To change your list options or unsubscribe, visit ... http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/evolution-list
