On Wed, 2010-07-14 at 18:34 +0100, David Woodhouse wrote: > > Personal Reply Non-Munged List > Munged List w/o Option Munged List with Option > > Ctrl-R to RT to RT to > RT to SA > > Ctrl-L to RT+CC to LP to > LP to LP > > Shift-Ctrl-R to RT+CC to LP+CC to > RT+CC to LP+CC > > > > Does that fit with what you're thinking? I'm ignoring nag screens, > > toolbar changes etc. for now. > > Where 'to RT' of course means 'to RT if it exists, else SA'. > > And 'to LP' means 'to LP if it exists, else to RT+CC'.(which in turn > means 'SA+CC' if there are no LP or RT headers, of course)
Naturally. I'm assuming "use the Reply-To header" has its usual meaning, i.e. use it if it exists, otherwise use the From: address, and so on. > All that is what I have implemented, *except* that there should be no > 'LP+CC' in the Shift-Ctrl-R row. It's 'RT+CC' for the first three > columns, and 'SA+CC' in the fourth where it ignores the Reply-To: > header. Makes sense. My head started to spin a little when creating the table :-) > But really, I don't *want* to see a table like this. The behaviour > should be *consistent* across all the columns, or we're just making > things more confusing and making errors more *likely*. The table is just between ourselves so we know we're on the same page. If by consistent you mean identical, I don't see how that's possible. The meaning of the various commands necessarily changes according to context. I agree this should be minimized, but I doubt it can be eliminated. > What we have > right now is: > > Ctrl-R: Uses the Reply-To: header if valid, else the From: header. > Ctrl-Shift-R: Uses the same as Ctrl-R, and adds the Cc: recipients. > Ctrl-L: Uses the List-Post: header if valid, else same as > Ctrl-Shift-R. > > A List-Post: header is considered valid if it exists. > > A Reply-To: header is considered valid if it exists, *unless* the > anti-munging option is set and there is a List-Post: header which > contains the same address. How is that different from the table (with your amendments)? > If we just take that and add an option to add 'Reply to List' to the > toolbar instead of 'Reply to All', how does that work for you? In addition to rather than instead of, to avoid mutable toolbars, but that's more a matter of personal taste. poc _______________________________________________ evolution-list mailing list [email protected] To change your list options or unsubscribe, visit ... http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/evolution-list
