Former TMers enjoy claiming that TM has the same effects as all other 
practices, but anyone who looks at the EEG signature of various practices 
instantly realizes that such people are either speaking from ignorance (willful 
or otherwise) or deliberately  lying. 
 

 

 Here's a discussion of no-self and American Buddhism in the context of a 
course on Buddhist philosophy and how it fits in with the research on Buddhist 
meditation (mindfulness, though focussed attention  practices such as Benson's 
Relaxation Response, Samatha and Metta, all have teh same overall effect):
 

 
http://www.patheos.com/blogs/americanbuddhist/2014/05/buddhism-and-modern-psychology-week-five-looking-at-meditation.html
 
http://www.patheos.com/blogs/americanbuddhist/2014/05/buddhism-and-modern-psychology-week-five-looking-at-meditation.html

 

 "Now that we’ve seen it suggested that the modular theory of the mind 
dovetails with the Buddhist theory of not-self, we look at how meditation might 
fit in to our picture.
 The first way this is discussed comes by looking at the Default Mode Network, 
which is the part of the brain that is active when our mind isn’t focused on 
anything. Brain scans have shown that meditation quiets this network. "
 The activation of the Default Mode Network (DMN) becomes greater during TM. 
Coincidentally, activation of teh DMN is associated with "sense of self," so 
the fact practice of meditation techniques that quiet the DMN also quiet "sense 
of self" is, well, a no-brainer. Likewise, the fact that TM, a mind-wandering 
practice, enhances teh activity of the DMN (including strengthening the 
activity of the brain associated with "sense of self") is a no surprising, 
either.
 

 People who insist that all meditation practices eventually lead to the "same 
place" are fooling themselves. Mindfulness and concentrative practices, in the 
long run, distort the functioning of the Default Mode Network. Maharishi called 
this "subtle damage" to the nervous system. TM enhances the normal restful 
functioning of the brain, aka the "Default Mode Network," which becomes active 
whenever the mind is allowed to wander.
 

 There's no reconciling the two approaches to spirituality.
 

 

Reply via email to