On 03/03/2014 12:58 PM, Anders Logg wrote:
On Mon, Mar 03, 2014 at 12:30:10PM -0600, Douglas N Arnold wrote:
My option is not (1). It is the typeset version of (1) for the
poster and (2) for UFL. By the typeset version, I means, e.g.,
the "e" in "RTe" and "N1e" are subscripts and the "1" in N1e
possibly a superscript.
ok
Thus for UFL, all the votes are in favor of (2), and the only
question is whether we should just reproduce the uppercase strings
of (2) on the poster or print it differently in a way that uses
case and scripts to clarify the meaning of the strings.
Each box in the poster has two names in it (in addition to the FEEC
notation): the one printed in large bold letters and the small one
below in the UFL code string.
The latter must definitely be the same as whichever option we pick for
UFL so (2). For the former, I think (1) would be the natural
choice. It already has a subscript _1, _2, _3 for the polynomial
degree r so it already differs from the UFL code string in that
respect.
So my vote would be Option (1) for the big bold names on the poster
but Option (2) for UFL (both in the poster and actual implementation).
I agree completely.
One tiny question remains concerning the poster. For the big bold name
of say N1E, degree 3, do we write $N^1_{e3}$ or $N1_{e3}$?
--
Anders
DNA
On 03/03/2014 12:01 PM, Anders Logg wrote:
In an attempt to summarize the opinions, I think we have landed at this:
* Two options: either mixed case or uppercase
Option (1)
P dP
P RTe/RTf dP
P N1e N1f dP
Option (2)
P DP
P RTE/RTF DP
P N1E N1F DP
In favor of (1): DNA
In favor of (2): MSA, (AL)
Option (1) has the advantage that it matches the names in the table.
Option (2) has the advantage of being all uppercase.
More votes?
* Adding aliases for convenience. I have absolutely no problem with
adding aliases in general, but suggest we wait and discuss each
suggested alias whenever it is proposed (later).
_______________________________________________
fenics mailing list
[email protected]
http://fenicsproject.org/mailman/listinfo/fenics
_______________________________________________
fenics mailing list
[email protected]
http://fenicsproject.org/mailman/listinfo/fenics
