--- DB Sommer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On 6/07/2007, at 04:14, DB Sommer wrote: > > > >> But, ironically, despite your encompassing the > entire world in your > >> reality warping powers, once youre defeated, > everything snapped > >> back to > >> normal, with only a handful at the center of your > defeat remember only > >> the faintest of details of your tampering. > Meaning your death today > >> will > >> change nothing of consequence in the future. > ... > > > >> This one didnt really fit in the proper Avengers > story, so it became a > >> side story. It also shows Kangs still active and > manipulating events. > >> It also uses the age old moral question of if > you could go back in > >> time > >> and kill Hitler as an infant, before he committed > the atrocities he > >> did, > >> would you do it? > > > > > > Bit of a stretch to compare Haruhi to Hitler, of > course. Though I > > suppose Kyon might not quite agree. :)
Okay, based on my knowledge of Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi, the premise completely does not work within the complete body of MoSH canon. This fic appears to be working off the Lone Goddess theory, which has been disproved in later canon. (Because the anime follows the novels very closely, and nothing in either conflicts at all with anything in the other, most fans consider that we have one canon in two formats, so you can't just say 'anime canon' for Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi. It's all one canon, and considering how the series is structured, later canon is incredibly important for early events.) But anyway, my point is, killing Haruhi will not solve Kang's problem. Lone Goddess [Haruhi is a god and everything is All Her Fault] has been disproved, and Two Gods [Haruhi and Kyon are both gods, and Kyon is just better at keeping his head down] is almost completely shot down too. The scenario could work for Lock and Key [Haruhi's powers are dependent on Kyon's presence and tacit permission] but is dependent on Haruhi being the only suitable Lock around for Kyon's Key (possible... but not likely). But if MoSH goes with Man Behind The Curtain [Kyon is the god and Haruhi is his avatar] (as seems increasingly likely with the way the novels are going), not only will that negate Kang's effort, he will have killed a god's (potential) avatar, and that god will not be happy. Raye ____________________________________________________________________________________ Need Mail bonding? Go to the Yahoo! Mail Q&A for great tips from Yahoo! Answers users. http://answers.yahoo.com/dir/?link=list&sid=396546091 --- .-------Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List--------. | Administrators - [EMAIL PROTECTED] | | Unsubscribing - [EMAIL PROTECTED] | | Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject | `------------ FAQ URL coming soon.... -------------'
