New submission from Chris <[email protected]>:
I tried to mux an AVI File w/o Audio and an Ac3 File, 448 kbps 5.1
together as AVI.
ffmpeg -i avi-wo-audio.avi -vcodec copy -i audio.ac3 -acodec copy -f avi
finished.avi
The Outcome has the Files Muxed together but no player can play the
Audio inside.
Video and Audio seperatley are correct. Muxed together on Windows using
AviMuxgui also works fine.
I added the Output from Avinaptic on the correct muxed file with
AviMuxGui and the second one is same Files muxed with FFMpeg.
FFmpeg Rev: FFmpeg version SVN-r25766, Copyright (c) 2000-2010 the
FFmpeg developers
Win32 Binary
---------------------------------------
1.
the correct one:
2.
-----------------
3.
4.
[ About file ]
5.
6.
Name: avimuxgui.avi
7.
Date: 19/11/2010 15:04:56
8.
Size: 856,971,912 bytes (817.272 MB)
9.
10.
[ Generic infos ]
11.
12.
Play duration: 01:21:47 (4907.28 s)
13.
Container type: AVI OpenDML indexes multi-chunks (*) rec-lists (*)
14.
Number of streams: 2
15.
Type of stream nr. 0: video
16.
Type of stream nr. 1: audio {audio}
17.
Audio streams: 1
18.
ISFT: AVI-Mux GUI 1.17.8.3, Feb 16 201019:42:50
19.
JUNK:
20.
21.
[ Relevant data ]
22.
23.
Resolution: VERY HIGH (720 x 400)
24.
Width: multiple of 16 (GOOD)
25.
Height: multiple of 16 (GOOD)
26.
Average DRF quality: HIGH (3.191861)
27.
Standard deviation quality: HIGH (0.795644)
28.
Std. dev. weighted mean: HIGH (0.465738)
29.
30.
[ Video track ]
31.
32.
FourCC: xvid/XVID
33.
Resolution: 720 x 400
34.
Frame aspect ratio: 9:5 = 1.8
35.
Pixel aspect ratio: 1:1 = 1
36.
Display aspect ratio: 9:5 = 1.8
37.
Framerate: 25 fps
38.
Number of frames: 122682 (258)
39.
Stream size: 578,745,974 bytes
40.
Bitrate: 943.489630 kbps
41.
Qf: 0.131040
42.
Key frames: 1282 (0; 300; 455; 755; 1055; ... 122552)
43.
Null frames: 0
44.
Min key int: 1
45.
Max key int: 300
46.
Avg key int: 95.695787
47.
Delay: 0 ms
48.
49.
[ Audio track ]
50.
51.
Audio tag: 0x2000 (AC3)
52.
Bitrate (container): 448 kbps CBR
53.
Channels (container): 6
54.
Sample rate (container): 48000 Hz
55.
Chunks: 76676
56.
Stream size: 274,806,784 bytes
57.
Preload: 192 ms
58.
Max A/V diff: 1176 ms
59.
AC-3 frames: 153352
60.
Play duration: 01:21:47 (4907.264 s)
61.
Chunk-aligned: Yes
62.
Mode: 3 front, 2 rear, 1 LFE
63.
Delay: 0 ms
64.
65.
[ About MPEG4 encoding ]
66.
67.
User data: XviD0050
68.
Packed bitstream: No
69.
QPel: No
70.
GMC: No
71.
Interlaced: No
72.
Aspect ratio: Square pixels
73.
Quant type: H.263
74.
Number of frames: 122682
75.
Drop/delay frames: 0
76.
Corrupted frames: 0
77.
78.
I-VOPs: 1282 ( 1.045 %)
79.
P-VOPs: 48021 ( 39.143 %) ##########
80.
B-VOPs: 73379 ( 59.812 %) ###############
81.
S-VOPs: 0 ( 0.000 %)
82.
N-VOPs: 0 ( 0.000 %)
83.
84.
Max consecutive B-VOPs: 2
85.
1 consec: 14775 ( 33.521 %) ########
86.
2 consec: 29302 ( 66.479 %) #################
87.
88.
[ DRF analysis ]
89.
90.
Average DRF: 3.191861
91.
Standard deviation: 0.795644
92.
Max DRF: 4
93.
94.
DRF<2: 0 ( 0.000 %)
95.
DRF=2: 29321 ( 23.900 %) ######
96.
DRF=3: 40502 ( 33.014 %) ########
97.
DRF=4: 52859 ( 43.086 %) ###########
98.
DRF>4: 0 ( 0.000 %)
99.
100.
I-VOPs average DRF: 2.370514
101.
I-VOPs std. deviation: 0.482942
102.
I-VOPs max DRF: 3
103.
104.
P-VOPs average DRF: 2.406218
105.
P-VOPs std. deviation: 0.491126
106.
P-VOPs max DRF: 3
107.
108.
B-VOPs average DRF: 3.720355
109.
B-VOPs std. deviation: 0.448824
110.
B-VOPs max DRF: 4
111.
112.
[ Profile compliancy ]
113.
114.
Profile to check: MTK PAL 6000
115.
Resolution: Ok
116.
Framerate: Ok
117.
Min buffer fill: 80%
118.
119.
This report was created by AVInaptic (18-11-2007) on 19 nov 2010,
h 15:06:04
120.
121.
122.
123.
124.
------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------
125.
126.
The FFMpeg result...
127.
-------------------
128.
129.
[ About file ]
130.
131.
Name: finished.avi
132.
Date: 19/11/2010 14:55:56
133.
Size: 860,248,970 bytes (820.397 MB)
134.
135.
[ Generic infos ]
136.
137.
Play duration: 01:21:47 (4907.28 s)
138.
Container type: AVI OpenDML
139.
Number of streams: 2
140.
Type of stream nr. 0: video
141.
Type of stream nr. 1: audio
142.
Audio streams: 1
143.
ISFT: Lavf52.84.0
144.
JUNK: odmldmlhø
145.
146.
[ Relevant data ]
147.
148.
Resolution: VERY HIGH (720 x 400)
149.
Width: multiple of 16 (GOOD)
150.
Height: multiple of 16 (GOOD)
151.
Average DRF quality: HIGH (3.191861)
152.
Standard deviation quality: HIGH (0.795644)
153.
Std. dev. weighted mean: HIGH (0.465738)
154.
155.
[ Video track ]
156.
157.
FourCC: XVID/XVID
158.
Resolution: 720 x 400
159.
Frame aspect ratio: 9:5 = 1.8
160.
Pixel aspect ratio: 1:1 = 1
161.
Display aspect ratio: 9:5 = 1.8
162.
Vprp aspect ratio: 9:5 = 1.8
163.
Framerate: 25 fps
164.
Number of frames: 122682
165.
Stream size: 578,745,974 bytes
166.
Bitrate: 943.489630 kbps
167.
Qf: 0.131040
168.
Key frames: 1282 (0; 300; 455; 755; 1055; ... 122552)
169.
Null frames: 0
170.
Min key int: 1
171.
Max key int: 300
172.
Avg key int: 95.695787
173.
Delay: 0 ms
174.
175.
[ Audio track ]
176.
177.
Audio tag: 0xfffe (Extensible wave format)
178.
Bitrate (container): 448 kbps VBR
179.
Channels (container): 6
180.
Sample rate (container): 48000 Hz
181.
Chunks: 153352
182.
Stream size: 274,806,784 bytes
183.
Delay: 0 ms
184.
185.
[ About MPEG4 encoding ]
186.
187.
User data: XviD0050
188.
Packed bitstream: No
189.
QPel: No
190.
GMC: No
191.
Interlaced: No
192.
Aspect ratio: Square pixels
193.
Quant type: H.263
194.
Number of frames: 122682
195.
Drop/delay frames: 0
196.
Corrupted frames: 0
197.
198.
I-VOPs: 1282 ( 1.045 %)
199.
P-VOPs: 48021 ( 39.143 %) ##########
200.
B-VOPs: 73379 ( 59.812 %) ###############
201.
S-VOPs: 0 ( 0.000 %)
202.
N-VOPs: 0 ( 0.000 %)
203.
204.
Max consecutive B-VOPs: 2
205.
1 consec: 14775 ( 33.521 %) ########
206.
2 consec: 29302 ( 66.479 %) #################
207.
208.
[ DRF analysis ]
209.
210.
Average DRF: 3.191861
211.
Standard deviation: 0.795644
212.
Max DRF: 4
213.
214.
DRF<2: 0 ( 0.000 %)
215.
DRF=2: 29321 ( 23.900 %) ######
216.
DRF=3: 40502 ( 33.014 %) ########
217.
DRF=4: 52859 ( 43.086 %) ###########
218.
DRF>4: 0 ( 0.000 %)
219.
220.
I-VOPs average DRF: 2.370514
221.
I-VOPs std. deviation: 0.482942
222.
I-VOPs max DRF: 3
223.
224.
P-VOPs average DRF: 2.406218
225.
P-VOPs std. deviation: 0.491126
226.
P-VOPs max DRF: 3
227.
228.
B-VOPs average DRF: 3.720355
229.
B-VOPs std. deviation: 0.448824
230.
B-VOPs max DRF: 4
231.
232.
[ Profile compliancy ]
233.
234.
Profile to check: MTK PAL 6000
235.
Resolution: Ok
236.
Framerate: Ok
237.
Min buffer fill: 80%
238.
239.
This report was created by AVInaptic (18-11-2007) on 19 nov 2010,
h 15:06:56
----------
messages: 12599
priority: normal
status: new
substatus: new
title: Muxxing AVI (w/o Audio) and 5.1 448 AC3 Creates crappy Files
type: bug
________________________________________________
FFmpeg issue tracker <[email protected]>
<https://roundup.ffmpeg.org/issue2371>
________________________________________________
