At 10/14/2002 01:04 PM, John Howell wrote:

 >When Eb Contra-Alto Clarinet parts are available with the score, they have
 >always been (from my experience) published in transposed treble 
clef.  Players
 >only use tuba parts when they are not available.

Yes, additionally,  Bari-sax parts can be used.

It depends on the existing players strengths and the particular chart.

Tuba parts often play with brass-only sections, where the reed sound is not 
appropriate.

 >You might think that the parts are rare, given the relative rarity of the 
instrument.  However,
 >I had treble clef transposed Eb contra-alto clarinet parts for almost 
every work I
 >performed last year.

Obviously, a group that performs medium-difficult works and higher.

Low clarinet parts are rare in Grade 3.

 >A few high school players were able
 >to personally adapt tuba parts, but I wonder whether some band directors were
 >even aware this was a possibility.

A good point.  I think I figured this out when I had a really excellent 
Bari-sax player in 7th grade and no tuba.  I had her play BOTH parts ;-)

I remember one year in high school band with no tuba player.  I had the 
Contra-alto player use a "reed" pickup and ran it through a preamp to make 
it sound less reedy, and amped it for concerts.  <Shudder> . . .  but it 
really made the band sound better overall.

A competition we went to, one of the judges said that, while a real tuba 
would have sounded better, he realized that small schools have to do the 
best they can.

Phil Daley          < AutoDesk >
http://www.conknet.com/~p_daley

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://mail.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to