1) Why are string fingerings taught by positions? does it result in the pupil learning to choose good fingerings quickly, or is it just the easiest way to teach?
There's a necessary logic to it. The first finger *has* to be located in one of a finite number of locations (assuming we're dealing with regular chromatic notes ;) ). There would be two options - number them 1-12 through the first octave, or, as is done, number them through a scale.
What tends to happen is that (beyond 1st position), the first that players become familiar with is third, and then fifth. Partly this is because these are the positions needed for the first 2 and 3 octave scales a player will learn. Partly I suspect it's through pedagogical habit. A *good* teacher will make sure that all the positions are dealt with through studies etc. Often this doesn't happen, so the muscle memory for these positions isn't developed as well, meaning that players find these positions awkward, meaning they avoid them further.
2) How were you taught and how do you choose fingerings now?
I was taught the 1st-3rd-5th route, as I described. Only much later was a given a thorough understanding of left-hand technique, and shown how to properly shift and how to properly train the hand in each position. Knowledge of good shifting technique makes choosing good fingering much easier.
3) I recall very little emphasis on positions when I was learning the 'cello and I was shifting from about the second lesson. I am self taught on the double bass and don't even know what position I am in most of the time. Players with a better technique than me seem to shift more than I do.
AFAIK, the wider gaps on the larger instruments make 'positions' less relevant, and shifting more frequent.
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
