In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> John Howell <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
Those of us who are NOT stuck in odd numbered positions are constantly fingering on the fly, and when we find the most comfortable fingerings we might even write them in! But I was trained not to think in positions but to use the entire fingerboard to enhance the sound by making certain fingering choices. It makes for some fun experimenting.
I find that very interesting, for several reasons.
1) Why are string fingerings taught by positions? does it result in the pupil learning to choose good fingerings quickly, or is it just the easiest way to teach?
Much in string playing (and not just in string playing!) is grounded in tradition, and stays around even when the original reasons no longer apply. I can't cite authority for this, but I do suspect that it relates to the fact that 18th century violinists not only did not use shoulder pads, but did not use chin rests either. (Just for comparison, my father, born in 1907, always used a chin rest but never used a shoulder pad, while I have never played without a pad!) The iconography shows a pretty uniform loose instrument position, with the instrument resting on the collar bone or even a bit lower, but not gripped or held fast. That means shifting up to higher positions was easy, since the left hand would be pressing the instrument against the collar bone or neck, but shifting down to lower positions was difficult, since the left hand would be pulling the instrument away from the body. Modern teachers of historical playing techniques use the chin (actually the jaw) to BRIEFLY grip the instrument on downshifts to solve this problem, and this makes sense of the scale manuals (I'm most familiar with Carl Flesch) which have 3-octave scales crawling up the E string with small shifts, but using wide leaps in coming down the E string. (18th century technique also means that a modern intense vibrato was impossible. It was not just a matter of taste and fashion, but a physical impossibility without a firm grip on the instrument. And vibrato was found in tables of ornaments, as a kind of trill.)
So, 1st position is a kind of home base, and 3rd position is a stable position because the wrist is against the instrument's body. Learning 5th position give a stable range up to F on the E string, which takes care of all but the most virtuosic music of the time. This sets up a mindset toward using, and teaching, the odd positions rather than both odd and even positions. The Sevcik etudes are definitely locked into individual positions. And even in a stable position it's easy enough to stretch the 4th finger up or extend the 1st finger back when needed, as cellists well know.
2) How were you taught and how do you choose fingerings now?
I started out learning traditional technique, with my father as my teacher. However, in the 1940s he took string pedagogy classes at Teachers College, Columbia University, with George Bornoff. Bornoff took a definitely non-traditional approach to string technique and string teaching, and my brother and I took private lessons with him as a demonstration to my father (and other skeptical class members) of the effectiveness of those non-traditional methods. Bornoff's goal was to open up the entire fingerboard instead of locking the student into set positions, allowing fingerings and alternate fingerings that were chosen for their sound and phrasing. He approached this goal, on the basic level, with one-finger scales up the fingerboard on single strings. Later (but not all that much later!) this became double-stop and artificial harmonic scales up the fingerboard. When I play above 3rd position, I quite literally do not know what position I am in, and do not care. That information has become irrelevant, while the actual sound that is produced is paramount. And I often spend as much time in 2nd position as in 1st or 3rd, because the fingering patterns are better in many passages.
I choose fingerings that, of course, work in the passages in question, but beyond that give me the musical sounds I decide are appropriate to the music. This is most important in solo music, of course, and has always been in the bag of tricks of an artist performer, but it can also be used in ensemble music. A passage that stays on the G string has an intensity that is missing when the same passage is played by crossing over to the D and A strings, for example, and artistic players have always known that.
3) I recall very little emphasis on positions when I was learning the 'cello and I was shifting from about the second lesson. I am self taught on the double bass and don't even know what position I am in most of the time. Players with a better technique than me seem to shift more than I do.
Yes, both cello and bass must start shifting much earlier than violin or viola students. Since Bornoff's "Finger Patterns" book (which was laid out for publication on the kitchen table of my parents' sublet New York appartment in the 1940s) was based on the methods he had developed as a violinist for teaching violin students, who can cover the interval of a 5th on a single string with the open string and 4 fingers, he needed supplements for the cello and bass books that introduced shifting much earlier so those instruments could play the same finger patterns (actually tonal patterns) on a single string along with the violins and violas. The cello supplement was written by Suzanne LeCarpentier, a fine cellist and teacher who was in Leonard Rose's class at Juilliard, and the bass supplement by Al Warner, who played violin concertos on his bass for fun!
Just for the record, Suzuki methodology (which can produce very fine results) is entirely a traditional approach, and as such can easily be added to a traditional teacher's bag of tricks. It remains focused on private lessons, in spite of the large ensemble demonstrations that first brought it to prominence after WW II. Bornoff methodology is such a radical departure from traditional teaching (including teaching positions) that it cannot be used as an add-on by traditional teachers. The teacher must learn not just what to do, but why it is done. This methodology also produces very fine results, and it was designed to be used in class teaching, producing those results in class lessons much more rapidly and efficiently than traditional methods and materials produce in private lessons. And Bornoff was giving large ensemble demonstrations in Winnipeg, Canada in the 1920s and 1930s, with students who had been taught entirely in classes rather than private lessons.
OK, I'm enthusiastic, and my mother and I wrote the book about Bornoff's life and work. What can I say!?
John
-- John & Susie Howell Virginia Tech Department of Music Blacksburg, Virginia, U.S.A 24061-0240 Vox (540) 231-8411 Fax (540) 231-5034 (mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]) http://www.music.vt.edu/faculty/howell/howell.html _______________________________________________ Finale mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
