Noel Stoutenburg wrote:

> It occurs to me, too, that Sibelius, in order to obtain the 
> competitive upgrade requires you to send them your MakeMusic! 
> distribution disk.

That's not how I read it.  It says on Sibelius's web site:

"You must provide proof of ownership of Finale, Encore, or Mosaic by mailing 
the first and second pages of your table of contents in your user manual or 
send us your original program CD."

So you can send a page or two from your manual, *or* the CD.  By contrast, on 
MM's web site, it says this:

"Mail the form, your Master Disk from a qualifying program and send to 
MakeMusic!"

So to get a crossgrade to Finale, you *do* have to send the CD.  You've got it 
all backwards, Noel!

(And all this stuff about the ETF file format being great because it's 
published: unless you're an accomplished programmer, you're never going to be 
able to make sense of the ETF format.  Have you looked at one latetly?  Not 
exactly human-readable!  And where exactly are the details of the format 
published?  Can you point me to a web site where I can download the details of 
the format?  If the information *is* freely-available, it's not well-publicised!

A much better format for storing data from notation applications in an 
application-independent way would be something like MusicXML.  Both Finale and 
Sibelius have export filters available for MusicXML as plug-ins, and because 
MusicXML *is* a published format and more or less human-readable to boot, I'd 
say it's much more suitable than ETF.  I don't work for the MusicXML folks, by 
the way.)

Best,
-WR
-- 
_______________________________________________
NEW! Lycos Dating Search. The only place to search multiple dating sites at 
once.
http://datingsearch.lycos.com


_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to