Yes, I follow you and concur for the tied note. I was just talking
about subsequent iterations of the pitch.
Ken
At 12:05 PM 9/8/2005, you wrote:
On 19:04 Uhr Ken Durling wrote:
Well, I'm not entirely sure being on system break or not affects
this question. If an accidental is tied across a barline it seems
to me it raises the question of subsequent identical pitches in the
following bar in either case, so that adding an accidental -
probably NOT courtesy but normal - should be the norm, as others are saying.
Well, by traditional European convention there should definitely not
be an accidental on a tied over note unless the tie goes over a
system break. All the editions I listed completely go by this convention.
Ken Durling
Composition and Music Services
Berkeley, CA
[510] 843-4419
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
