From: Johannes Gebauer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: [Finale] OT: recorders for the 4th Brandenburg
To: Finale <[email protected]>
I have sort of lost touch with this discussion, but I remember that
there are theories that Bach wrote the 4th Brandenburg concerto for
recorder instruments not in F but in G. Can anyone here shed some light
on this for me? Would such instruments have been built for a pitch of
415 Hz?
Johannes
--
------------------------------
Although much of the passage work is much easier on a treble recorder in G,
the fact that the second recorder has to play low Fs but shares the same
high passages with the first means that only recorders in F could be
intended (I suppose it might be possible that the first should be in G and
the second in F, but that would create problems of matching the sounds).
There is certainly a problem for recorder players, since many instruments
cannot play a top F# in tune. My own transitional-style recorders have no
problems with these passages, although the tone quality is not as good as on
a baroque-style instrument. Maybe there are aspects of construction of
recorders of that time that modern makers have failed to identify, or
players are using the wrong sort of instruments.
Regards,
Michael Lawlor
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale