On Jan 25, 2010, at 2:44 AM, Eric Fiedler wrote:
I hear what you're saying...and sometimes a local solution is the best and only way to go in a pinch. But on the other hand, there's something about a score with a number of different spacing algorithms that doesn't look quite right to me. As I understand it, the old engravers of yesteryear used one set of spacings for a whole piece or movement, which _did_ require a lot of calculations before hammering in the first note punch, but which produced results which are easy to read and in addition exude a wonderful kind of harmonious "rightness" that has a lot to do with the overall graphical balance between black and white on the page. Or am I being too fussy here? I'd be interested in your take on the subject — or anybody's take, for that matter.
My theory is that a consistent spacing look across the entire piece is always the goal, but a uniform set of Finale note spacing values is not the best way to achieve that goal.
I guess that means I'm assuming the engraver knows better than the program what looks good, and he will use the program as a tool to achieve it. A constant note-spacing variable is extremely useful to that and will be used most of the time, but there will be times when it's better to depart from that, and I'm trusting the engraver to know when it's appropriate.
If the argument against a feature is that some users will use it to produce uglier work, there are plenty more things you'd have to oppose. (For one thing, 75% of desktop publishers shouldn't be allowed to have more than eight typefaces....)
mdl _______________________________________________ Finale mailing list [email protected] http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale
