Further inline comments(in bold) below:
Douglas Knudsen wrote: > > I've made comments inline below. > > DK > > On Mon, Jul 14, 2008 at 5:36 AM, Manu Dhanda <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > wrote: >> >> Hii all, >> >> Here I want to have your opinion considering all three (Flex, Cairngorm & >> callback function) together. >> >> My consideration and approach is to utilize the Cairngorm's command class >> (execute method) to perform the required actions/tasks. >> In a few scenario's, when it comes to sequencing, that also can be >> achieved >> using "SequenceCommand" or dispatching another custom event in the >> responder's result/fault to sequence it. > > This can make the command coupled to your view in a way, consider some > other gesture needing to result in this same command being enacted? > > Whatever else is listening to this event you call at the end will > react and you may not want it to. > > Shouldn't we utilize the model in this scenario(in accordance with view > and command's responses). > > > You may want to look at the EventGenerator instead of SequenceCommand > > I still have to explore it(Cairngorm Extensions). Looks promising to a few > hurdles with original Cairngorm. > >> >> So, now can anyone give me advantages of using callback function?? > > The Callback avoids the above. > > Don't you think that callback will ruin the flow of app this way( as u r > handling/guiding the flow of app somewhere in the view), where as it > should be in accordance with controller/model. > Or is there any major advantages for that(maybe am missing something, > still learning). > > Thanks, > Manu. >> >> And why (or why not) it should be used? >> Whether it's a good approach using callback in Cairngorm >> MicroArchitecture? >> And if we using it, ain't we loosing the focus, the flow of application >> altogether ? >> >> Looking for some thoughts at this topic from you guyz. >> >> Thanks. >> -- >> View this message in context: >> http://www.nabble.com/Flex%2C-Cairngorm---callback-function-tp18440431p18440431.html >> Sent from the FlexCoders mailing list archive at Nabble.com. >> >> > > > > -- > Douglas Knudsen > http://www.cubicleman.com > this is my signature, like it? > > -- View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/Flex%2C-Cairngorm---callback-function-tp18440431p18456678.html Sent from the FlexCoders mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
